The Effects of a Transition to Minimalist Shoe Running on Intrinsic Foot Muscle Size

Abstract

A proposed benefit of minimalist shoe running is an increase in intrinsic foot muscle strength. This study examined change in intrinsic foot muscle size in runners transitioning to Vibram FiveFingers™ minimalist shoes compared to a control group running in traditional running shoes. We compare pre-transition size between runners who developed bone marrow edema to those who did not. 37 runners were randomly assigned to the Vibram FiveFingers™ group (n=18) or control group (n=19). Runners’ bone marrow edema and intrinsic foot muscle size were measured at baseline and after 10 weeks. Total running volume was maintained by all runners. A significant increase in abductor hallucis cross-sectional area of 10.6% occurred in the Vibram FiveFingers™ group compared to the control group (p=0.01). There was no significant change in any of the other muscles examined (p>0.05). 8 of the Vibram FiveFingers™ runners, and 1 control runner developed bone marrow edema. Those who developed bone marrow edema, primarily women, had significantly smaller size in all assessed muscles (p≤0.05). Size of intrinsic foot muscles appears to be important in safely transitioning to minimalist shoe running. Perhaps intrinsic foot muscle strengthening may benefit runners wanting to transition to minimalist shoes.

Key words

abductor hallucis - ultrasound imaging - barefoot running - bone marrow edema - Vibram FiveFingers

• References

• 1 Ansede G, Lee JC, Healy JC. Musculoskeletal sonography of the normal foot. Skeletal Radiol 2010; 39: 225-242
• 2 Busseuil C, Freychat P, Guedj EB, Lacour JR. Rearfoot-forefoot orientation and traumatic risk for runners. Foot Ankle Int 1998; 19: 32-37
• 3 Cameron AF, Rome K, Hing WA. Ultrasound evaluation of the abductor hallucis muscle: Reliability study. J Foot Ankle Res 2008; 1: 12
• 4 Crofts G, Angin S, Mickle KJ, Hill S, Nester CJ. Reliability of ultrasound for measurement of selected foot structures. Gait Posture 2014; 39: 35-39
• 5 Erickson SJ. Sonography of the foot and ankle. Foot Ankle Clin 2000; 5: 29-48 v
• 6 Fiolkowski P, Brunt D, Bishop M, Woo R, Horodyski M. Intrinsic pedal musculature support of the medial longitudinal arch: an electromyography study. J Foot Ankle Surg 2003; 42: 327-333
• 7 Harriss DJ, Atkinson G. Ethical standards in sport and exercise science research: 2014 update. Int J Sports Med 2013; 34: 1025-1028
• 8 Jenkins DW, Cauthon DJ. Barefoot running claims and controversies: a review of the literature. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc 2011; 101: 231-246
• 9 Kadambande S, Khurana A, Debnath U, Bansal M, Hariharan K. Compartive anthropometric analysis of shod and unshod feet. The Foot 2006; 16
• 10 Kura H, Luo ZP, Kitaoka HB, An KN. Quantitative analysis of the intrinsic muscles of the foot. Anat Rec 1997; 249: 143-151
• 11 Lazzarini KM, Troiano RN, Smith RC. Can running cause the appearance of marrow edema on MR images of the foot and ankle?. Radiology 1997; 202: 540-542
• 12 Lieberman DE. What we can learn about running from barefoot running: an evolutionary medical perspective. Exerc Sport Sci Rev 2012; 40: 63-72
• 13 Lieberman DE, Venkadesan M, Werbel WA, Daoud AI, D’Andrea S, Davis IS, Mang’eni RO, Pitsiladis Y. Foot strike patterns and collision forces in habitually barefoot versus shod runners. Nature 2010; 463: 531-535
• 14 Mickle KJ, Nester CJ, Crofts G, Steele JR. Reliability of ultrasound to measure morphology of the toe flexor muscles. J Foot Ankle Res 2013; 6: 12
• 15 Miller EE, Whitcome KK, Lieberman DE, Norton HL, Dyer RE. The effect of minimal shoes on arch structure and intrinsic foot muscle strength. J Sport Health Sci 2014; 3: 74-85
• 16 Perkins HM, Bond EA, Thompson J, Woods EC, Smith C. Realtime ultrasound: an objective mearsure of skeletal muscle. Phys Ther Rev 2003; 8: 99-108
• 17 Pohl MB, Hamill J, Davis IS. Biomechanical and anatomic factors associated with a history of plantar fasciitis in female runners. Clin J Sports Med 2009; 19: 372-376
• 18 Rao UB, Joseph B. The influence of footwear on the prevalence of flat foot. A survey of 2300 children. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1992; 74: 525-527
• 19 Reeser LA, Susman RL, Stern Jr JT. Electromyographic studies of the human foot: experimental approaches to hominid evolution. Foot Ankle 1983; 3: 391-407
• 20 Reimers CD, Finkenstaedt M. Muscle imaging in inflammatory myopathies. Curr Opin Rheumatol 1997; 9: 475-485
• 21 Ridge ST, Johnson AW, Mitchell UH, Hunter I, Robinson E, Rich BS, Brown SD. Foot bone marrow edema after a 10-wk transition to minimalist running shoes. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2013; 45: 1363-1368
• 22 Rolian C, Lieberman DE, Hamill J, Scott JW, Werbel W. Walking running and the evolution of short toes in humans. J Exp Biol 2009; 212: 713-721
• 23 Rothschild CE. Primitive running: a survey analysis of runners’ interest, participation, and implementation. J Strength Cond Res 2012; 26: 2021-2026
• 24 Willems TM, Witvrouw E, De Cock A, De Clercq D. Gait-related risk factors for exercise-related lower-leg pain during shod running. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2007; 39: 330-339
• 25 Williams 3rd DS, McClay IS, Hamill J. Arch structure and injury patterns in runners. Clin Biomech (Bristol, Avon) 2001; 16: 341-347
• 26 Wong YS. Influence of the abductor hallucis muscle on the medial arch of the foot: a kinematic and anatomical cadaver study. Foot Ankle Int 2007; 28: 617-620