Key words
thioacetals - imidodiphosphates - Brønsted acid catalysis
The synthesis of optically active organic sulfur compounds is of interest because of their high abundance in natural products and pharmaceuticals.[1] Sulfur-based scaffolds are also widely used as chiral ligands, auxiliaries, catalysts, and intermediates in chemical synthesis.[2] However, despite the high synthetic utility of (achiral) dithioacetals,[3] little attention has been given to the development of asymmetric methods for the synthesis of their chiral, enantiopure analogues, which may have interesting biological properties.[4] We now report highly enantioselective direct thioacetalization reactions of aldehydes with dithiols catalyzed by a nitrated imidodiphosphoric acid.[5]
Previous approaches towards enantioenriched dithioacetals involve either Diels–Alder reactions of dithioesters with dienes or electrophilic sulfenylations of sulfur-substituted active methines.[6] In contrast, the conceptually straightforward direct dithioacetalization of carbonyl compounds with dithiols has long remained unknown. Inspired by recent studies on chiral Brønsted acid catalyzed direct asymmetric acetalization reactions and related transformation, proceeding via oxocarbenium-[7] and iminium ions,[8] we became curious if an asymmetric thioacetalization, which would proceed via a thionium ion as the critical intermediate, would also be realizable. Remarkably though, while catalytic asymmetric reaction that proceed via iminium ions are well established, and those involving oxocarbenium ions are currently being developed,[7]
[9] thionium ions, to our knowledge, have not previously been invoked as critical intermediate in a catalytic enantioselective transformation. Success in developing a catalytic asymmetric thioacetalization of aldehydes would therefore also constitute a proof-of-principle of the general utility of thionium ions in asymmetric catalysis.
We began our investigations by reacting 2-methylpropane-1,2-dithiol (1a) with hydrocinnamaldehyde (2a) to give dithiolane 3a in trifluorotoluene in the presence of 5 Å molecular sieves at room temperature (Table [1]). A catalytic amount of TRIP (4) was tested for the thioacetalization reaction, but did not lead to any conversion after 10 days (entry 1). Based on our previous studies regarding asymmetric spiroactelizations,[7c] O,O-acetalizations,[7d]
[e] sulfoxidations,[10a] and carbonyl-ene cyclizations,[10b] we set to explore the ability of our chiral confined imidodiphosphoric acid catalysts to perform an asymmetric thioacetalization reaction. Indeed, both imidiodiphosphoric acids 5a and 5b afforded the expected thioacetal 3a with an excellent 98:2 er (entries 2 and 3). However, the reactivity at room temperature turned to be moderate and full conversion was obtained after 3 days.
Table 1 Reaction Developmenta
|
Entry
|
Catalyst (mol%)
|
Time
|
Conv.b
|
erc
|
1
|
4 (5)
|
10 d
|
0%
|
–
|
2
|
5a (5)
|
3 d
|
full
|
98:2
|
3
|
5b (5)
|
3 d
|
full
|
98:2
|
4
|
6 (5)
|
2 h
|
full
|
98:2
|
5
|
6 (2)
|
24 h
|
full
|
98:2
|
a Reactions were run on a 0.05 mmol scale.
b Determined by 1H NMR analysis.
c Determined by HPLC analysis.
We have recently designed more active imidodiphosphoric acid catalysts by increasing their acidity either via backbone nitration or by replacing a P=O group with a P=NTf group.[9f]
[g] Gratifyingly, the use of 5 mol% of unsymmetrical catalyst 6 led to significantly increased reactivity and product 3a was obtained with full conversion after only 2 hours with an er of 98:2 (entry 4). Lowering the catalyst loading to 2 mol% gave full conversion within 24 hours while retaining the excellent enantioselectivity (entry 5).
The aldehyde scope of the enantioselective thioacetalization reaction was investigated next (Table [2]). Reacting aldehyde 2a with dithiol 1a furnished product 3a in 90% isolated yield and with an er of 98:2 (entry 1).[11] The use of pentanal led to the formation of product 3b with 84% yield and an excellent er of 98:2 (entry 2). Isovaleraldehyde and the α-branched aldehyde 2d gave access to the corresponding dithiolanes 3c and 3d with good yields and excellent enantioselectivities (entries 3 and 4). A significantly lower er of 74:26 of product 3e was obtained when benzaldehyde was subjected to the reaction conditions (entry 5). Our method can also be applied to acetalizations with a 1,3-dithiol to access six-membered thioacetals.[12] 1,3-Dithiane 3f was obtained with slightly lower er (90:10) compared to the corresponding dithiolane (entry 6 vs. entry 1). In addition, lower yield was obtained due to the non-negligible formation of the corresponding enethiol ether (see Supporting Information). Thioacetalization of (E)-cinnamaldehyde with 4,4-dimethyl-2-phenethyl-1,3-dithiane (1b) proceeded with good enantioselectivity giving product 3g with an er of 92:8 (entry 7). Pentanal and isovaleraldehyde could be employed in the reaction to give product 3h and 3i with enantiomeric ratios of 89:11 and 91.5:8.5, respectively (entries 8 and 9). Replacing isovaleraldehyde with α-branched aldehyde 2d resulted in lower enantioselectivity (er = 85.5:14.5) and reactivity (51% yield, entry 10).
Table 2 Reaction Scopea
|
Entry
|
Temp
|
Time
|
Product
|
Yield (%)
|
erb
|
1
|
r.t.
|
24 h
|
3a
|
90
|
98:2
|
2
|
r.t.
|
24 h
|
3b
|
84
|
98:2
|
3
|
r.t.
|
24 h
|
3c
|
82
|
98.5:1.5
|
4
|
r.t.
|
24 h
|
3d
|
86
|
99:1
|
5
|
r.t.
|
38 h
|
3e
|
88
|
74:26
|
6c
|
0 °C
|
24 h
|
3f
|
73
|
90:10
|
7c
|
–20 °C
|
2 d
|
3g
|
80
|
92:8
|
8c
|
0 °C
|
24 h
|
3h
|
46
|
89:11
|
9c
|
0 °C
|
2 d
|
3i
|
73
|
91.5:8.5
|
10c
|
0 °C
|
6 d
|
3j
|
51
|
85.5:14.5
|
a Reactions were run on a 0.2 mmol scale in trifluorotoluene with 40 mg of 5Å MS.
b Determined by HPLC analysis or GC analysis.
c 5 mol% of catalyst were used.
Based on our previous studies on the O,O-acetalization reaction of aldehydes,[7d] we suggest the following mechanism (Scheme [1]). Nitrated imidodiphosphate catalyst 6 activates both the aldehyde and the dithiol simultaneously to lead to the formation of S,O-hemiacetal–imidodiphosphoric acid complex A. Protonative dehydration of complex A results in the formation of the crucial thionium ion intermediate B. Cyclization directed by the chiral imidodiphosphate anion leads to enantioenriched product 3 with regeneration of the catalyst.
Scheme 1 Postulated mechanism
In summary, we have developed an enantioselective direct thioacetalization reaction of aldehydes with dithiols. Various enantioenriched dithiolanes and dithianes have been obtained with excellent enantioselectivities and in high yields.