The Upward Spiral of Drug Costs: A Time Series Analysis of Drugs Used in the Treatment of Hemophilia

Summary

Background

Hemophilia is an expensive disease because its treatment is heavily dependent on costly clotting factor drugs. Over the last nine years, a consortium of three Comprehensive Hemophilia Treatment Centers and other hospitals, which purchased clotting factors for their patients, has seen treatment costs escalate on average 17% annually. Currently, new, even more expensive drugs are entering the market.

Methods

This study analyzes 3,244 purchases that were made over a nine-year period totaling nearly 500 million units of clotting factor, representing every product on the market. Purchases were made both apart from and under the Federal Public Health Service (PHS) discount pricing rules.

Findings

The main cause of the increases was the move to newer, more expensive products. The average price of existing products increased less than 2% per year, but new products were priced, on average, 47% higher than existing products. Overall consumption increased by an average of 5% per year, likely reflecting prophylactic treatment modalities that require greater amounts of clotting factor. Government pricing programs, such as the PHS program, were ineffective or counterproductive at reducing costs.There is a notable absence of competition in this market, with a few dominant companies having a functional monopoly in the largest segments of the market. Prices of older products are not lowered, even when new products are brought to market. A few products that serve small patient groups have had their prices increased substantially.

Interpretation

This escalation is likely to continue as new, more expensive clotting factor drugs are developed. Since these new products are not proven to be any safer or more effective than the current products, this situation creates a risk of intervention by government and insurers to address both treatment costs and exhaustion of patients’ insurance caps. Drug companies are not serving the patients by pricing new, but often very similar, products so aggressively. The trends seen in this patient group will likely be seen in other patient groups in the future. Ultimately, doctors and patients will lose treatment options and health care availability unless collaborative strategies are developed to reduce costs.

Keywords

Hemophilia - clotting factor - pharmaceutical pricing

• References

• 1 United States General Accounting Office. “Prescription Drugs: Expanding Access to Federal Prices Could Cause Other Price Changes”. August 2000 GAO/HEHS-00-118.
• 2 Soucie JM, Nuss R, Evatt B. et al. Mortality among males with hemophilia: relations with source medical care. Blood 2000; 96: 437-42.
• 3 Soucie JM, Evatt B, Jackson D. Occurrence of hemophilia in the United States. The Hemophilia Surveillance System Project Investigators. Am J Hematol 1998; 59: 288-4.
• 4 Larrson SA. Life expectancy of Swedish hemophiliacs, 1831-1980. Br J Haematol 1985; 59: 593-602.
• 5 Hoyer LW. Hemophilia A. N Engl J Med 1994; 330: 38-47.
• 6 Ginsburg D. Hemophilia and other inherited disorders of hemostasis and thrombosis. In: Rimoin DL, Connor JM, Pyeeritz RE, Emry AEH. eds Emery and Rimoin’s Principles and Practice of Medical Generics, sol II. New York: Churchill Livingstone; 1997: 1651-76.
• 7 Hoyer LW. The incidence of factor VIII inhibitors in patients with severe hemophilia A. In Aledort LM, Loyer LW, Lusher JM, Reisner HM, White II GC. eds Inhibitors to Coagulation Factors. New York: Plenum Press; 1995: 33-45.
• 8 Ewing NP, Sanders NL, Dietrich SL, Kasper CK. Induction of immune tolerance of factor VIII in hemophiliacs with inhibitors. JAMA 1988; 259: 65-8.
• 9 McClelland DBL. Safety of human albumin as a constituent of biologic therapeutic products. Transfusion 1998; 38: 690-9.
• 10 The National Hemophilia Foundation: Medical and Scientific Advisory Council. MASAC Medical Advisory #312. February 1998
• 11 New York State Department of Health. Hemophilia Treatment in New York State. 1998
• 12 Roberts P. The Marketing Research Bureau, Inc. Survey on Hemophilia Care & Price Monitoring: United States Wave #10. April 2000 Orange, Connecticut.
• 13 Roberts P. The Marketing Research Bureau, Inc. Survey on Hemophilia Care & Price Monitoring: United States Wave #10. April 2000 Orange, Connecticut.
• 14 Reinhardt U. The New York Times, Op-Ed article. January 3, 2001
• 15 DiMichele D, Neufeld EJ. Hemophilia: A new approach to an old disease. Hematol Oncol Clin North Amer 1998; 12: 1315-44.
• 16 42 U. S. C. A. Section 139 6r-8.
• 17 United States General Accounting Office, “Prescription Drugs: Expanding Access to Federal Prices Could Cause Other Price Changes”. August 2000 GAO/HEHS-99-118.
• 18 Code of Federal Regulations 42 C. F. R. 405.517.
• 19 Code of Federal Regulations 42 U. S. C. A. 256 (b).
• 20 Code of Federal Regulations 42 U. S. C. A. 1396r-8-(b) (3) (c).
• 21 Code of Federal Regulations 42 U. S. C. A. 256b.
• 22 HEHS-94-194FS August 5 1994