The single greatest impediment to the successful leveraging of computer-based patient records (CPRs) is the difficulty of creating and maintaining comparable patient descriptions. Specifically, it will be hard to justify the investment required to deploy CPRs widely if the patient descriptions they store are not comparable across successive releases of controlled health-care vocabularies. Thus, it is necessary to solve the controlled health-care vocabulary update problem for CPRs before the comparability of patient descriptions can be sustained. What may seem to be a narrow technical problem of interest only to maintainers of health-care enterprise systems is, instead, a central problem of medical informatics. Cimino’s “Formal descriptions and adaptive mechanisms for changes in controlled medical vocabularies” describes a classification of the changes appearing in the 1994 Edition of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-9-CM). His paper describes the conversion of differences detected between the 1993 and 1994 releases of ICD-9-CM and a conversion of the elements of the classification into the required formal changes to the Medical Entities Dictionary (MED), part of the CPR in use at Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center. Because the process of detecting differences begins with an empirical analysis of the ASCII representations of the 1993 and 1994 releases of ICD-9-CM, it is impossible for a computer program to infer the intent of the changes that caused the differences; instead, a content expert must infer the intent and then update the MED accordingly. A typical task is to infer whether a change in naming also reflects a change in the meaning named. While Cimino’s methods and their execution are exemplary in every respect, they nevertheless constitute a kind of “reverse engineering” – an ad hoc attempt to infer intent from details. Reverse engineering of changes to controlled medical vocabularies is a poor precedent. Such methods should be viewed as necessary short-term expedients only, and all parties concerned should work toward an incremental plan by which the intent of changes to controlled health-care vocabularies can be made both explicit and machine processible. Only then can the comparability of patient descriptions be sustained.
References
1
Masys D.
The informatics of health care reform. Bull Med Libr Assoc 1996; Jan 84 (01) 11-6.
2
United States National Center for Health Statistics.
International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Edition, with Clinical Modifications. Washington, DC: 1980
7
UNIX User’s Reference Manual. 4.3 Berkeley Software Distribution, USENIX Association.
(copyright by the Regents of the University of California and Bell Telephone Laboratories), April 1986
9
Russell B.
A History of Western Philosophy. Copyright by Bertrand Russell, 1945, reprinted by Book of the Month Club and Simon Schuster; 1995: 155-6 Interestingly, for readers of this journal, Russell acknowledges the support of a physician, Dr. Albert C. Barnes, founder of the Barnes Foundation in Pennsylvania; the book was originally a series of lectures presented to that foundation.
11
Nelson SJ,
Cole WG,
Tuttle MS.
et al. Recognizing New Medical Knowledge Computationally.
Safran C.
ed. Proc Annu Symp Comp Appl Med Care 1993; 409-13.
12
Cimino JJ,
Clayton PD,
Hripscak G,
Johnson SB.
Knowledge-based approaches to the maintenance of a large controlled medical terminology. J Am Med Informatics Association 1994; 1 (03) 202-17.
13
Rector AL,
Nowlan WA,
Glowinski A.
Goals for the Concept Representation in the Galen Project.
Safran C.
ed. Symposium on Computer Applications in Medical Care. Washington, DC: McGraw-Hill; 1993: 414-8.
15
Campbell KE,
Cohn SP,
Chute CG.
et al. Galapagos: Computer-based Support for Evolution of a Convergent Medical Terminology. 1996 AMIA Fall Meeting. (to appear).
17
Côté RA,
Rothwell DJ,
Palotay JL.
The Systematized Nomenclature of Human and Veterinary Medicine (SNOMED International). College of American Pathologists; Northfield, Illinois: 1993
19
Tuttle MS.
Book Reviews: E Davis, Representations of Commonsense Knowledge, and DB Lenat and RV Guha, Building Large Knowledge-Based Systems: Representations and Inference in the Cyc Project. Artificial Intelligence 61 1993; 121-48.
23
Detmer MD Don E..
in an address to the
NLM/AHCPR Electronic Medical Record (EMR) Collaborative.
April 1996. Dr. Detmer was formerly the Chair of the Institute of Medicine (IOM) Committee on Improving the Patient Record in Response to Increasing Functional Requirements and Technological Advances. The committee’s report appeared as
Dick RS,
Steen EB.
Editors. The Computer-based Patient Record: An Essential Technology for Health Care. National Academy Press; Washington, DC: 1991
25
Tuttle MS,
Sherertz DD,
Erlbaum MS.
et al. Adding your terms and relationships to the UMLS Metathesaurus.
Clayton PD.
ed. Proc. Annu Symp Comp Appl Med Care 1991; 219-23.
26
UMLS Knowledge Sources.
7th Experimental Edition. January 1996. Unified Medical Language System, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. National Institutes of Health, National Library of Medicine.;
29
Shortliffe E,
Barnett GO,
Cimino J.
et al. Collaborative medical informatics research using the Internet and the World Wide Web. Proc. 1996 Fall AMIA Meeting. (to appear).
30
Oliver DE,
Shortliffe EH.
The InterMed Collaboratory.
Collaborative Model Development for Vocabulary and Guidelines. Proc. 1996 AMIA Fall Meeting. (to appear).
31
Tuttle MS,
Suarez-Munist ON,
Olson NE.
et al. Merging Terminologies.
Greenes RA,
Petersen HE,
Protti DJ.
eds. MED INFO 95. Vancouver, Canada: 1995: 162-6.
32
Suarez-Munist ON,
Hole WT,
Irons RJ.
et al. MEME II: An environment for managing meaning (Poster Abstract). Proc Annu Symp Comput Appl Med Care 1995; 956.
35
Olson NE,
Sherertz DD,
Erlbaum MS.
et al. Explaining your terminology to a computer (Poster Abstract). Proc Annu Symp Comput Appl Med Care 1995; 957.
36
Tuttle MS,
Campbell ICE,
Olson NE.
et al. Concept, code, term and word: preserving the distinctions (Poster Abstract). Proc Annu Symp Comput Appl Med Care 1995; 956.
39
Brodie ML,
Stonebraker M.
Migrating Legacy Systems: Gateways, Interfaces and the Incremental Approach. Morgan Kaufman Publishers; San Francisco: 1995