Health-Care Technology Transfer: Expert and Information Systems for Developing Countries

Abstract:

Computer-based technologies such as information systems and expert systems have an undoubted contribution to health-care development in developing countries. This paper addresses the appropriateness of these technologies for developing countries, the criteria to be used in selection of the technology to be transferred, and the need for a systematic approach to evaluation. A conceptual model for assessing transferability so as to achieve an effective transfer, has been introduced. This requires not only an attempt to amplify the role of information and expert systems in health-care improvement and for socio-economic development, but the analysis of prior experience in transferring these technologies to developing countries. Following this approach, and using operational research techniques such as the Analytic Hierarchy Process, a subjective assessment model has been described that can systematically guide decision-making about computer-based health-care technology to be transferred to developing countries.

Keywords:

Information Technology - Medical Expert Systems - Technology Transfer - Developing Countries

• References

• 1 Kahen G, Sayers B McA. The Context of Technological Change in Developing Countries .... The Proceeding of the (IAMOT) European Conference on Management of Technology. Birmingham: 1995
• 2 Kahen G. A Comprehensive and Strategic Model of Technology Transfer: Emphasising IT. The IS UK PH. D. Consortium. Cranfield: 1994
• 3 Kahen G. Integrating Energy Planning and Techno-economic Development: A Solid Basis for the Assessment and Transfer of Energy Technology to Developing Countries. The First loint Int. Symposium on Energy Models for Policy and Planning. London Business School/International Federation of Operational Research Societies; London: July 18–20 1995
• 4 Kahen G, Sayers B McA. IT and National Development in the Third World .... The 5th Int Conf. of the Information Resources Management. Association. USA: 1994
• 5 Kahen G, Sayers B McA. Modelling Global-Oriented Energy Technology Transfer to DCs. The 6th Global Warming Int. Conference. USA: 1995
• 6 Panerai RB, Pena Mohr J. Health Technology Assessment: Methodologies for Developing Countries. Washington: Pan American Health Organisation; 1989
• 7 Nakajima H. “WHO Response to Global Change”, World Health Forum Int. Journal of Health Development 1995; 16: 212-14.
• 8 Kahen G, Sayers B McA. Modelling Optimal Allocation of Foreign Exchange for Technological Import Needs in DCs. The Proceeding of the 5th Conf. on Monetary and Foreign Exchange Policies. Iran: 1995
• 9 Kahen G, Griffiths C. Human Factors, Technology Transfer, and Information Technology in the Socio-Economic Development of the Third World. The Proceeding of the IT-DEV’ 95. Johannesburg: 1995
• 10 Sayers McA B. Engineering in the Health Sciences. The Impact of Scientific Advances on Future Health, Report of A WHO-CIOMS Colloquium. Charlottesville, Virginia: June 1995
• 11 Kahen G. Assessment of Information Technology for Developing Countries: Appropriateness, Local Constraints, IT Characteristics and Impacts. Int. Journal of Computer Applications in Technologies. 1995; 5 6 325-32.
• 12 Avgerou C, Land F. Examining the Appropriateness of Information Technology. In: Odedra M, Bhatnagar SC. (eds.) Social Implications of Computers in Developing Countries. New Delhi: Tata McGraw Hill; 1992
• 13 King K, Beck H. Medical AI Systems as Appropriate Technology for Developing Countries. The Knowledge Engineering Review 1990; 5: 251-63.
• 14 Kigada M. Directory of Telecommunications services in Africa. The International Development and Research Centre (IDRC). 1991
• 15 Networks Group. Status of Networking in Africa. Consortia Pis a Research. Italy: Publishers BV; 1992
• 16 Rodriguez AJ. The East and Southern Africa Network: Technical and Management Perspectives. The Proceedings of Int. Federation for Information Processing International Conference. Egypt: 3–5 January 1995
• 17 Kogi K, Sen RN. Third World Ergonomics. In: Oborne OJ. (ed.) International Reviews of Ergonomics. London: Taylor and Francis; 1987
• 18 Walsh am G. et al. Information Systems as Social Systems: Implications for developing countries. In: Bhatnagar SC. Bjorn-Anderson (eds.) Information Technology in Developing Countries. Amsterdam: North Hoiland; 1990
• 19 Madon S. The Impact of Computer-Based Information Systems on Rural Development: A Case Study in India. Unpublished Ph. D. Thesis Imperial College of Science, Technology and Medicine; London, UK: 1992
• 20 Forster D. Expert Systems in Health for Developing Countries: Practice, Problems and Potential. Report No. IDRC-MR319e. Ottawa: Int. Development Research Centre; 1992
• 21 Korpela M. Nigerian Practice in Computer Systems Development: A multi-disciplinary the oretical framework. Ph.D. Thesis Helsinki University of Technology; Finland: 1994
• 22 Nabarro D. et al. Microcomputers in Developing Country Programmes: Valuable tools or troublesome toys?. In: Wilson R. G. et al. (eds.) Management Information systems and Microcomputers in Primary health-care. Geneva: Aga Khan Foundation; 1988
• 23 Silva L. Health Information Systems in Developing Countries: Who should be responsible?. Paper presented in a seminar organised by the British Computer Society Developing Countries Specialist Group. LSE; London, UK: 1994
• 24 IEEE Trans. Software Engineering. Special Issue on Artificial Intelligence and Software Engineering. Mostow: J. (guest editor) 1995. 11 No. 11
• 25 Balzer R. A 15-Year Perspective on Automatic Programming. IEEE Trans. Software Engineering 1985; 11: 1257-67.
• 26 Ben-Bassat M. et al. Pattern-based interactive diagnosis of multiple disorders: The MEDAS System. IEEE Trans Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence 1980; PAMI-21 148-60.
• 27 Goldschlager L, Lister A. Computer Science: A Modern Introduction. New York: Prentice Hall; 1988
• 28 Ben-Bassat M. The role of expert systems in clinical diagnosis: A conceptual tutorial. The Proceeding of 4th Jerusalem Conference on Information Technology. May 21–25 Jerusalem, Israel: 1984
• 29 Blois MS. Clinical Judgement and Computers. New England Journal of Medicine 1983; 303: 192-7.
• 30 Cornford T. et al. 1994; Experience with a Structure, Process and Outcome Framework for Evaluating an Information System. Omega 22 (05) 491-504.
• 31 King K. Artificial Intelligence of Developing Countries: Promises and Possibilities. In: Social Implication of Computers in Developing Countries. New Delhi: McGraw-Hill; 1992
• 32 Goldberger H, Schwenn P. Man-machine Symbiosis in the Assistance and Training of Rural Health workers: A Proposal. In: Pages J. et al. (eds.) Meeting the Challenge: Informatics and Medical Education. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science; 1983
• 33 Christian B. et al. Health and Socio-economic Development: An Intersectoral Model. Social Science and Medicine 1997; 11: 63-9.
• 34 Silk DJ. Managing IS Benefits for the 1990s. Journal of Information Technology 1990; 5: 185-93.
• 35 Symons V. Evaluation of Information Systems: IS Development in the Processing Company. Journal of Information Technology 1990; 5: 194-204.
• 36 Blennerhassett R. Planning for Information Technology in the Health Service. MBA Thesis Imperial College; London, UK: 1992
• 37 Light OW. Effectiveness and Efficiency under Competition: The Cochrane Test. British Medial Journal 1991; 303: 1253-54.
• 38 Tapscott D. Office Automation: A user driven method. New York: Plenum Press; 1982
• 39 Chantler C. Management and Information. British Medial Journal 1992; 304: 632-35.
• 40 Nickerson RS. Why interactive computer systems are sometimes not used by people who might benefit from them. Int. Journal of Man-Machine Studies 1981; 15: 469-83.
• 41 Gould JD. et al. Making usable, useful, productivity-enhancing computer applications. Communications of the ACM 1991; 34: 74-85.
• 42 Hales M. A human resource approach to information systems development – the ISU (information systems use) design model. Journal of Information Technology 1991; 6: 140-61
• 43 McCarroll T. What new age?. Time 12. Aug. 1991; 138: 44-6.
• 44 Davies BT. Why Ergonomics for Developing Countries?. In: Shahnavaz H, Babri M. eds. Proceeding of the First Int. Conference on Ergonomics of Developing Countries. Lulea, Sweden: June 16–17 1983
• 45 Branscomb LM, Thomas Je. Ease of use: A system design challenge. IBM Systems Journal 1985; 23: 224-35.
• 46 Villforth JC. Role of Regulatory Authorities in Technology Transfer. WHO Meeting of Regional Advisers on Technology Development, Assessment and Transfer. Geneva: 17–21 June 1991
• 47 Akehurst R, Buxton MJ. A guide to better decision making: option appraisal in the NHS. Folio No.8, Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust. London: 1985
• 48 Osuntokun BO. Problems and Opportunities in the absorption of Technology. WHO Meeting of Regional Advisers on Technology Development, Assessment and Transfer. Geneva: 17–21 June 1991
• 49 Green A. An Introduction to Health Planning in Developing Countries. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1995
• 50 Edge D. The Social Shaping of Technology. In: Heap N. et al. Information Technology and Society. London: Sage Publications Ltd; 1995
• 51 Fransman M. Conceptualising Technical Change in the Third World in the 1980s: An interpretive survey. Journal of Development Studies 1985; 21: 572-652.
• 52 Fransman M. A Biological Approach to New Technological Knowledge. Background Paper for ESRC Industry and Employment Committee Initiative in New Technology. 1985
• 53 Mackenzie D, Wajcman J. The Social Shaping of Technology. Milton Keynes: Open University Press; 1985
• 54 Villela GF. Problems and Solutions in the Process of Computerising Patient Wards in Third World Hospitals. The Proceedings of MIE ’93. Freund: 1993
• 55 Kahen G. Institutionalising Technology Transfer within a Multi Dimensional Context: The Japanese Style. The Proceeding of the Int. Conference on Japanese Information in S&T. Newcastle: 1995
• 56 Thorp J. Informatics for Medicine as it Affects Developing Countries: An Eastern European Experience. Paper presented in a seminar organised by the British Computer Society. LSE; London: 8. November 1994
• 57 WHO. Managerial Process for National Health Development: Guiding principle for use in support of strategies for Health for All by Year 2000. Health for All Series 1981; (05) 58.
• 58 Hurley J. et al. Geographicallydecentralised Planning and Management in health-care. Social Science and Medicine 1995; 41: 483-89.
• 59 Saaty TL. The Analytic Hierarchy Process. New York: McGraw Hill; 1980
• 60 Saaty TL. Decision Making for Leaders. Belmont, CA: Van Nostrand Reinhold; 1982
• 61 Johnson CR. Constructive critique of a hierarchical prioritisation scheme employing paired comparisons:. Proceedings of the Int. conference of Cybernetics and Society of the IEEE, Institute of Electrical Engineers. Cambridge, Massachusetts: 1980
• 62 Roper GC, Sharp JA. The Analytic Hierarchy Process and its Application to an Information Technology Decision. Journal of Operation Research Society 1990; 41: 49-59.