Administration of 100 % Oxygen in Diving Accidents - An Evaluation of Four Emergency Oxygen Devices

As the use of oxygen enhances the resorption of gas bubbles in decompression illness, it is recommended and generally accepted that the inspired oxygen concentration in emergency treatment of diving accidents has to be as close to 100 % as possible. Therefore, several emergency oxygen devices are offered to the diving community but only with little data in literature on the efficacy of these devices. We tested four emergency oxygen devices with respect to efficacy of oxygen supply and breathing comfort at rest. Nine blinded volunteers had to breathe from the four systems with face mask and mouthpiece as well. Gases were measured with mass spectrometry during a 3 min interval from a capillary port close to the subject. The results showed that none of the systems was able to deliver 100 % oxygen all the time, but in three systems inspiratory oxygen values were achieved, although in one system the nitrogen wash-out was slowed due to air contamination during inspiration. The fourth tested system frequently supplied the subjects simply with air while breathing at rest. We conclude from our study that it is difficult to achieve oxygen levels close to 100 % in practice. Even in a perfectly working system, the interface between device and subject is a source of entrained air, especially when oxygen breathing has to be performed over a longer period of time. In addition, two of four systems had conceptional problems to supply the subjects with pure O₂ during inspiration. None of the tested systems was perfectly designed to serve in such emergencies.

Key words:

SCUBA diving, diving accident, oxygen treatment, oxygen demand systems.

References

• 1 Annane D, Trouché G, Delisle F, Devauchelle P, Paraire F, Raphl J C, Gajdos P. Effects of mechanical ventilation with normobaric oxygen therapy on the rate of air removal from cerebral arteries.  Crit Care Med. 1994;  22 851-857
• 2 Behnke A R, Shaw L A. The use of oxygen in the treatment of compressed air illness.  Nav Med Bull. 1937;  35 61-73
• 3 Bert P. Barometric Pressure (La Pression Barometrique). Bethesda; Undersea medical Society 1978
• 4 Bethune D W, Collis J M. The evaluation of oxygen masks. A mechanical method.  Anaesthesia. 1967;  22 43-54
• 5 Braun U, Hudjetz W. Duration of preoxygenation in patients with normal and impaired lung function.  Anaesthesist. 1980;  29 125-131
• 6 Davis M. Oxygen therapy equipment: a theoretical review.  SPUMS Journal. 1998;  28 165-172
• 7 Desola J, Sala J, Rebella A, Geronimo C, Montaya J. Transcutaneous oxygen concentrations achieved with 5 different normobaric delivering systems. A comparative study (preliminary report). Helsinki; Presented at: EUBS XXlst Annual Meeting 1995
• 8 Everatt J, Ng W S. Pre-oxygenation using face mask or mouthpiece with and without nose clip: patient preferences and efficacy.  Anaesthesia. 1998;  53 387-389
• 9 Fowler K T. The respiratory mass spectrometer.  Phys Med Biol. 1969;  14 185-199
• 10 Gillbe C E, Heneghan C P, Branthwaite M A. Respiratory mass spectrometry during general anaesthesia.  Br J Anaesth. 1981;  53 103-109
• 11 Goddard J M. Concentrations of oxygen delivered by air entrainment of oxygen masks.  Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 1985;  67 366-367
• 12 Hirsch J A, Bishop B. Human breathing patterns on mouthpiece or face mask during air, CO₂, or low O₂.  J Appl Physiol. 1982;  53 1281-1290
• 13 Komesaroff D. Oxygen administration in diving accidents.  SPUMS Journal. 1998;  28 (Suppl.) 20-25
• 14 McGowan P, Skinner A. Preoxygenation - the importance of a good face mask seal.  Br J Anaesth. 1995;  75 777-778
• 15 Melamed Y, Shupak A, Bitterman H. Medical problems associated with underwater diving.  N Engl J Med. 1992;  326 30-34
• 16 Mertzlufft F. Prüfung des Oxidem-Systems. In: Mertzlufft F (ed.) System zur Oxygenierung von Patienten durch Nutzung des intrapulmonalen Sauerstoffspeichers. Thesis 1993.  Homburg/Saar, Germany; University Clinics of Saarland University 1993 77-79, 109-111, 137-138
• 17 Moon R E, Dear G L, Stolp, BW. Treatment of decompression illness and iatrogenic gas embolism.  Respir Clin N Am. 1999;  5 93-135
• 18 Moon R E, Sheffield P J. Guidelines for treatment of decompression illness.  Aviat Space Environ Med. 1997;  68 234-243
• 19 Muth C M, van Laak U. Das Wenoll-System - Erprobung eines Sauerstoffrückatmungssystems für den Tauchunfall.  Caisson. 1993;  8 242-246
• 20 Roberts M J, Boustred M L, Hinds C J. A multipatient mass spectrometer based system for the measurement of metabolic gas exchange in artificially ventilated intensive care patients.  Intens Care Med. 1983;  9 339-343
• 21 Safar P, Lind B. Triple airway maneuver, artificial ventilation and oxygen inhalation by mouth-to-mask and bag-valve-mask techniques. National Conference on Standards for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiac Care. Dallas; American Heart Assoc. WG 205 N273p 1975, 1973, 1976 Jun 2: 49-58
• 22 Shinnick M A. Recognition of scuba diving accidents and the importance of oxygen first aid.  J Emerg Nurs. 1994;  20 105-110
• 23 Stephenson R N, Mackenzie I, Watt S J, Ross J A. Measurement of oxygen concentration in delivery systems used for hyperbaric oxygen therapy.  Undersea Hyperbaric Med. 1996;  23 185-188
• 24 Stewart R D, Kaplan R, Pennock B, Thompson F. Influence of mask design on bag-mask ventilation.  Ann Emerg Med. 1985;  14 403-406
• 25 Stout R L, Jewell E D, Wessel H U, Paul M H. Mass spectrometer for multiple respiratory gas analysis.  Biomed Tech (Berl). 1975;  20 165-171
• 26 Vann R D, Thalmann E D. Decompression physiology and practice. In: Bennett P, Elliott D, (eds.) The physiology and medicine of diving. London; Saunders 1993 4th edition: 376-432
• 27 Winship S, Skinner A. Vital capacity and tidal volume preoxygenation with a mouthpiece.  Br J Anaesth. 1998;  81 787-789