A Morphometric Study of Populations of the Centaurea jacea Complex (Asteraceae) in Belgium

Abstract

The Centaurea jacea aggregate is a polymorphic polyploid complex whose taxonomic treatment is still controversial. A numerical taxonomic approach was applied to 394 individuals of known ploidy level, from 19 populations, based on the main diagnostic characters proposed in earlier revisions. Populations from xeric grasslands were not considered. Principal Component Analysis shows that variation within the complex is continuous. UPGMA Cluster Analysis based on population means supports the recognition of three groups of populations. However, the limits between these groups are blurred to a considerable extent due to extensive within-population polymorphism. It is argued that the Belgian populations of Centaurea jacea occurring in mesic grasslands should be treated as a single species, with three subspecies. The two extremes of the morphological gradient can be referred to as C. jacea subsp. jacea and C. jacea subsp. nigra, with C. jacea subsp. pratensis occupying an intermediate position. Most populations from Belgium are tetraploid, a diploid chromosome number being found only in populations of C. jacea subsp. nigra from the Ardennes massif. On average, diploids grow at higher altitude and on more acidic soils than tetraploids. Finally, a key to the three subspecies is provided.

Key words

Knapweeds - numerical taxonomy - polyploidy - flow cytometry - Centaurea nigra - Centaurea jacea - Centaurea pratensis

References

• 01 Arènes,  J.. (1939) Etude sur les Composées Cynarocéphales de la flore française. II, les Centaurées de la sous-section Eujaceae Boiss. Paris; Cynarocéphales de France 4
• 02 Arènes,  J.. (1954);  Les Composées-Cynarocéphales de Belgique.  Bulletin du Jardin Botanique de l'Etat (Bruxelles). 24 290-311
• 03 Arènes,  J.. (1957);  Les Centaurées de la sous-section Jacea. .  Systématique, chorologie et phylogénie. Bulletin du Jardin Botanique de l'Etat (Bruxelles). 27 143-157
• 04 Briquet,  J.. (1931) Composées Cynaroïdées. Flore des Alpes maritimes, Vol. VII. Burnat E., Briquet J., and Cavillier, F., eds. Genève; pp. 7
• 05 Cottenie,  A.,, Verloo,  M.,, Kiekens,  L.,, Velghe,  G.,, and Camerlynck,  R.. (1982) Chemical analysis of plants and soils. Ghent, Belgium; Laboratory of analytical and agrochemistry, State Univ.
• 06 Dostál,  J.. (1976) Centaurea L. Flora Europaea, Vol. IV. Tutin T. G. et al., eds. Cambridge; Cambridge University Press pp. 254-301
• 07 Duvigneaud,  J., and Saintenoy-Simon,  J.. (1997);  Centaurea nigra. Sa description, son écologie, sa distribution dans nos régions.  Adoxa. 15/16 29-32
• 08 Galbraith,  D. W.,, Harkins,  K. R.,, Maddox,  J. M.,, Ayres,  N. M.,, Sharma,  D. P.,, and Firoozabadi,  E.. (1983);  Rapid flow cytometry analysis of the cell cycle in plant tissues.  Science. 220 1049-1051
• 09 Gardou,  C.. (1972);  Recherches biosystématiques sur la Section Jacea Cass. et quelques sections voisines du genre Centaurea L. en France et dans les régions limitrophes.  Feddes Repertorium. 83 311-472
• 10 Guinochet,  M.. (1982) Centaurea L. Flore de France, 4. Guinochet, M. et de Vilmorin, R. Paris; Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique pp. 1499-1511
• 11 Hardy,  O. J.,, Vanderhoeven,  S.,, de Loose,  M.,, and Meerts,  P.. (2000);  Ecological, morphological and allozymic differentiation between diploid and tetraploid knapweeds (Centaurea jacea) from a contact zone in the Belgian Ardennes.  New Phytologist . 146 281-290
• 12 Hardy,  O. J.,, Vanderhoeven,  S.,, Meerts,  P.,, and Vekemans,  X.. (2000);  Spatial autocorrelation of allozyme and quantitative markers within a natural population of Centaurea jacea (Asteraceae).  Journal of Evolutionary Biology. 13 656-667
• 13 Hayek,  A. V.. (1918);  Kritische Studien über den Formenkreis der Centaurea jacea L. s. l.  Verh. Zool. Bot. Ges. Wien. 68 159-214
• 14 Jahier,  J.,, Chevre,  A. M.,, Eber,  F.,, Delourme,  R.,, and Tanguy,  A. M.. (1992) Techniques de cytogénétique végétale. Paris; INRA éditions
• 15 Kerguélen,  M.. (1993) Index synonymique de la flore de France. Paris; Muséum national d'histoire naturelle
• 16 Lambinon,  J.,, De Langhe,  J.-E.,, Delvosalle,  L.,, and Duvigneaud,  J. (et coll.). (1993) [“1992”] Nouvelle Flore de la Belgique, du Grand-Duché de Luxembourg, du Nord de la France et des Régions voisines (Ptéridophytes et Spermatophytes) ed. 4. Meise; Editions du Patrimoine du Jardin Botanique National de Belgique
• 17 Marsden-Jones,  E. M., and Turrill,  W. B.. (1954) British Knapweeds, a study in synthetic taxonomy. London; Royal Society
• 18 Saarisalo-Taubert,  A.. (1966);  A study of hybridization in Centaurea, section Jacea, in Eastern Fennoscandia.  Annales Botanici Fennici. 3 86-95
• 19 Sokal,  R. R., and Rholf,  F. J.. (1995) Biometry. New York; Freeman and Co.
• 20 Sommer,  S.. (1990) Isozymanalyse zur Ermittlung genetischer Variabilität und mikroevolutiver Prozesse bei Centaurea sect. Jacea (Asteraceae). Universität Bayreuth; Dissertation zur Erlangung des Doktorgrades der Naturwissenschaften
• 21 Stace,  C.. (1997) New Flora of the British Isles, ed. 2. Bath; Cambridge University Press
• 22 Van der Meijden,  R. (et coll.). (1996) Heukels' Flora van Nederlands, ed. 22. Groningen; Wolters-Noordhoff
• 23 van Soest,  J. L.. (1947);  Centaurea sectie Jacea en het voorkomen in Nederland.  Nederl. Kruidkund. Archief. 54 69-106
• 24 Weeda,  E. J.,, Westra,  R.,, Westra,  C.,, and Westra,  T.. (1991) Nederlandse oecologische Flora. Wilde planten en hun relaties, Vol. 4. Hilversum; IVN
• 25 Wisskirchen,  R., and Haeupler,  H. (et coll.). (1998) Standardliste der Farn- und Blütenpflanzen Deutschlands. Stuttgart; E. Ulmer

Section Editor: H. Prach