Adherence and Attrition With Intermittent and Continuous Exercise in Overweight Women

Abstract

Few people are active to the levels recommended by Healthy People 2010. Intermittent exercise has been promoted as an exercise prescription which may enable more people to meet recommended guidelines. However, few data are available on intermittent exercise over the long-term. The purpose of the current study was to compare the effects of long-term (72 weeks) continuous (CON) and intermittent (INT) exercise on attrition and adherence in previously sedentary, moderately obese females. Participants were randomized to continuous walking at 60 to 75 % of maximum aerobic capacity, 3 days per week, 30 minutes per session, or intermittent exercise for two 15-minute sessions, 5 days per week. Adherence was calculated as the number of sessions completed compared to the number of sessions prescribed. At 12-week intervals, attrition was calculated as the number of participants in the study compared to the total number of participants originally enrolled. For the participants who completed the study, body weight decreased for CON from 80.17 ± 5.75 kg at baseline to 79.70 ± 5.40 at 16 months (p < 0.05). For INT, body weight did not change from baseline (85.85 ± 13.13 kg) to 16 months (85.05 ± 12.90 kg). By design, INT walked significantly (p < 0.05) further (819 ± 128 km) compared to CON (527 ± 46 km). Attrition was 58 % for both groups baseline to 72 weeks. However, attrition was greater for CON (38 %) compared to INT (16 %) in the first 24 weeks. Adherence was excellent for both groups (> 83 %) throughout the study. These results suggest that intermittent and continuous exercise both have considerable attrition rates within 72 weeks of exercise initiation; however, the pattern of attrition differs considerably. That is, it appears that intermittent exercise may reduce attrition in the first 24 weeks of an exercise program; however, attrition does not appear to be different than continuous exercise at 72 weeks.

Long-term - body weight - body composition - adherence - attrition - prescription

References

• 1 American Heart Association .Exercise testing and training of apparently healthy individuals: a handbook for physicians. The committee on exercise, American Heart Association #70-008-A, Dallas, TX: 1972
• 2 Balon R, Arfken C L, Mufti R. Patients’ preferences about medication dosing regimens.  Psychiatric Services. 1998;  49 1095-1097
• 3 Brownson R C, Jones D A, Pratt M, Blanton C, Heath G W. Measuring physical activity with the behavioral risk factor surveillance system.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;  32 1913-1918
• 4 Brozek J, Grande F, Andersen J T, Keys A. Densiometric analysis of body composition: revision of some quantitative assumptions.  Ann N Y Acad of Scienc. 1963;  110 113-140
• 5 Cramer J A. Optimizing long-term patient compliance.  Neurology. 1995;  45 S25-S28
• 6 Dishman R K, Sallis J F, Orenstein D R. The determinants of physical activity and exercise.  Pub Health Rep. 1985;  100 158-171
• 7 Donnelly J E, Jacobsen D J, Heelan K S, Seip R, Smith S. The effects of 18 months of intermittent vs. continuous exercise on aerobic capacity, body weight and composition, and metabolic fitness in previously sedentary, moderately obese females.  Int J Obes. 2000;  24 566-572
• 8 Donnelly J E, Jacobsen D J, Jakicic J M, Whatley J, Gunderson S, Gillespie W J, Blackburn G L, Tran Z V. Estimation of peak oxygen consumption from a sub-maximal half mile walk in obese females.  Int J Obes. 1992;  16 585-589
• 9 Donnelly J E, Jacobsen D J, Snyder K A, Seip R L. Effects of long-term, moderate intensity, intermittent exercise on weight loss and body composition.  Int J Obes. 2000;  25 566-572
• 10 Farmer K C, Jacobs E W, Phillips C R. Long-term patient compliance with prescribed regimens of calcium channel blockers.  Clin Therapeutics: Int Peer Rev J Drug Ther. 1994;  16 316-326
• 11 French S A, Jeffery R W, Murray D. Is dieting good for you? Prevalence, duration and associated weight and behavior changes for specific weight loss strategies over four years in US adults.  Int J Obes. 1999;  23 320-327
• 12 Grandits G A, Bartsch G E, Stamler J. Method issues in dietary data analyses in the Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial.  Am J Clin Nutr. 1997;  65 211-227
• 13 Jakicic J M, Wing R R, Butler B A, Robertson R J. Prescribing exercise in multiple short bouts versus one continuous bout: Effects on adherence, cardiorespiratory fitness, and weight loss in overweight women.  Int J Obes. 1995;  19 893-901
• 14 Jakicic J M, Winters C, Lang W, Wing R R. Effects of intermittent exercise and use of home exercise equipment on adherence, weight loss, and fitness in overweight women - A randomized trial.  JAMA. 1999;  282 1554-1560
• 15 King A C, Blair S N, Bild D E, Dishman R K, Dubbert P M, Marcus B H, Oldridge N B, Paffenbarger Jr R S, Powell K E, Yeager K K. Determinants of physical activity and interventions in adults.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1992;  24 221-236
• 16 Martin S B, Morrow Jr. J, Jackson A W, Dunn A L. Variables related to meeting the CDC/ACSM physical activity guidelines.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;  32 2087-2092
• 17 Murphy M H, Hardman A E. Training effects of short and long bouts of brisk walking in sedentary women.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1998;  30 152-157
• 18 NIH Technical Assessment Conference . Panel Methods for voluntary weight loss and control.  Ann Int Med. 1992;  116 942-949
• 19 Pate R R, Pratt M, Blair S N, Haskell W, Macera C A, Bouchard C, Buchner D, Ettinger W, Heath G W, King A C, Kriska A, Leon A S, Marcus B H, Morris J, Paffenbarger R S Jr, Patrick K, Pollock M L, Rippe J M, Sallis J, Wilmore J H. Physical activity and public health: A recommendation from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the American College of Sports Medicine.  JAMA. 1995;  273 402-407
• 20 Sallis J F, Haskell W L, Wood P D, Fortmann S P, Rogers T, Blair S N, Paffenbarger R S Jr. Physical activity assessment methodology in the five-city project.  Am J Epidemiol. 1985;  121 91-106
• 21 Snyder K A, Donnelly J E, Jacobsen D J, Hertner G, Jakicic J M. The effects of long-term, moderate intensity, intermittent exercise on aerobic capacity, body composition, blood lipids, insulin and glucose in overweight females.  Int J Obes. 1997;  21 1180-1189
• 22 Verbrugge L M, Gruber-Baldini A L, Fozard J L. Age differences and age changes in activities: Baltimore longitudinal study of aging.  J Gerontol. 1996;  51 30-41
• 23 Withers R T, Smith D A, Tucker R C, Brinkman M, Clark D G. Energy metabolism in sedentary and active 49- to 70-yr-old women.  J Appl Physiol. 1998;  84 1333-1340