Evidence for the Polyphyly of Haworthia (Asphodelaceae Subfamily Alooideae; Asparagales) Inferred from Nucleotide Sequences of rbcL, matK, ITS1 and Genomic Fingerprinting with ISSR-PCR

Abstract

Four molecular markers have been studied to examine the phylogenetic position of the South African plant genus Haworthia Duval within the succulent Asphodelaceae. Sequence data of the chloroplast genes matK and rbcL were compared to the nuclear markers ITS1 and ISSR (Inter Simple Sequence Repeat) analysis. Both lines of molecular data, chloroplast and nuclear DNA, indicate that Haworthia is polyphyletic, forming two distinct clades. Most taxa previously combined as Haworthia subgenus Haworthia branch off early in the alooid chloroplast trees forming a strongly monophyletic group, whereas subgenus Hexangulares forms a polyphyletic assemblage comprising other alooid genera. The nuclear markers ITS1 and ISSR fingerprinting support the two groups as distinctly different, therefore confirming the division seen in chloroplast DNA. The practical implication is that the generic concept of Haworthia may have to be restricted to H. subgenus Haworthia or alternatively, that the groups of Haworthia be treated as infrageneric taxa within a broadened (Linnaean) concept of Aloe.

Haworthia - Inter Simple Sequence Repeat (ISSR) - nuclear internal transcribed spacer (ITS) - maturase K (matK) - ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase large subunit (rbcL) - phylogeny

References

• 1 Bayer B.. The new Haworthia Handbook. National Botanic Gardens of South Africa, Kirstenbosch. (1982)
• 2 Bayer B.. Haworthia Revisited. A Revision of the Genus. Hatfield; Umdaus Press (1999)
• 3 Breuer I.. An Haworthia species concept update.  Alsterworthia International Special Issue. (2002);  1 1-24
• 4 Chase M. W., De Bruijn A. Y., Cox A. V., Reeves G., Rudall P. J., Johnson M. A. T., Eguiarte L. E.. Phylogenetics of Asphodelaceae (Asparagales): an analysis of plastid rbcL and trnL-F DNA sequences.  Annals of Botany. (2000);  86 935-951
• 5 Doyle J. J., Doyle J. L.. Isolation of plant DNA from fresh tissue.  Focus. (1990);  12 13-15
• 6 Duval H. A.. Plantae succulentae, in horto Alenconio. Paris; Apud Gabon et Socios (1809)
• 7 Haworth A. H.. A new arrangement of the genus Aloe, with a chronological sketch of progressive knowledge of that genus, and other succulent genera.  Transactions of the Linnean Society of New York. (1804);  7 1-28
• 8 Jacobsen H.. Haworthia Duval: review of sections and species.  Sukkulentenkunde. (1951);  4 97
• 9 Jacobsen H.. The genus Haworthia Duval.  Kakteen und andere Sukkulenten. (1965);  3 7
• 10 Linnaeus C.. Species plantarum. Stockholm; Salvius (1753)
• 11 Martin W., Salamini F.. A meeting at the gene. Biodiversity and natural history.  EMBO reports. (2000);  1, 3 208-210
• 12 Scott C. L.. A revision of the genus Haworthia, section Retusae. .  Aloe. (1973);  11 8
• 13 Scott C. L.. The Genus Haworthia (Liliaceae). A Taxonomic Revision. Johannesburg; Aloe Books (1985)
• 14 Smith G. F., Meyer N.. Asphodelaceae. Leistner, O. A., ed. Seed Plants of Southern Africa: Families and Genera. Pretoria; National Botanical Institute, Strelitzia 10 (2000): 582-586
• 15 Smith G. F., Van Wyk B.-E.. Generic relationships in the Alooideae (Asphodelaceae). .  Taxon. (1991);  40 557-581
• 16 Smith G. F., Van Wyk B.-E.. Asphodelaceae. . Kubitzki, K., ed. The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants , III. Flowering Plants. Monocotyledons, Lilianae (except Orchidaceae). Berlin; Springer-Verlag (1998): 130-140
• 17 Smith G. F., Van Wyk B.-E., Steyn E. M. A., Breuer I.. Infrageneric classification of Haworthia (Aloaceae): perspectives from nectar sugar analysis.  Systematics and Geography of Plants. (2001);  71 391-397
• 18 Swofford D. L.. PAUP-Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony. Version PAUP 4.0b10. Sunderland, Massachusetts; Sinauer Associates, Inc. Publishers (2003)
• 19 Treutlein J., Smith G. F., Van Wyk B.-E., Wink M.. Phylogenetic relationships in the Asphodelaceae (subfamily Alooideae) inferred from chloroplast DNA sequences (rbcL, matK) and from genomic fingerprinting (ISSR).  Taxon. (2003);  52 193-207
• 20 Uitewaal A. J. A.. A first attempt to subdivide the genus Haworthia, based on floral characters.  Desert Plant Life. (1947 a);  19 132-136
• 21 Uitewaal A. J. A.. Revision of the nomenclature of the genera Haworthia and Apicra. .  Succulenta. (1947 b);  26 51-54
• 22 Uitewaal A. J. A.. Views on the classification of Haworthias.  Cactus and Succulent Journal of Great Britain. (1949);  11 19
• 23 Van Wyk B.-E., Viljoen A. M., Dagne E.. Chemotaxonomic Studies in African Aloaceae and Asphodelaceae. Kampala; Proc. 6th NAPRECA Symp. Nat Prod. (1995): 15-18
• 24 Wijnands D. O.. The Botany of the Commelins. Rotterdam; A. A. Balkema (1983)
• 25 Wink M., Sauer-Gürth H., Martinez F., Doval G., Blanco G., Hatzofe O.. The use of (GACA)₄ - PCR to sex Old World vultures (Aves: Accipitridae).  Molecular Ecology. (1998);  7 779-782
• 26 Wink M., Guicking D., Fritz U.. Molecular Evidence for Hybrid Origin of Mauremys iversoni Pritchard et McCord, 1991, and Mauremys pritchardi McCord, 1997 (Reptilia: Testudines: Bataguridae). Zoologische Abhandlungen. Staatliches Museum für Tierkunde Dresden (2001): 41-49
• 27 Zietkiewicz E., Rafalski A., Labuda D.. Genome fingerprinting by Simple Sequence Repeat (SSR)-anchored Polymerase Chain Reaction Amplification.  Genomics. (1994);  20 176-183

Section Editor: F. Salamini