ABSTRACT
We describe here results from the United Kingdom National External Quality Assessment Scheme (UK NEQAS) Thrombophilia Screening Program, in which an average of 21% of 280 centers reported an incorrect diagnosis for a series of plasma samples. Three case studies are described, showing causes of error in individual laboratories, related to the source of reference plasma or reagents. Methodological bias is also described. For protein C (PC) assays 18% of centers reported PC deficiency in a patient homozygous for factor V Leiden. Studies in the NEQAS laboratory confirmed the effect of activated protein C resistance (APCR) on clot-based PC activity assays. Differences in results obtained for PS-deficient subjects with different protein S (PS) activity kits are reported; several subjects would be misdiagnosed as normal with one kit if the manufacturer's reported reference range was adopted instead of a locally determined reference range. Antithrombin (AT) assays were shown to vary in their sensitivity to different molecular defects in the antithrombin gene; 77% of centers employing human thrombin-based activity assays reported a normal AT level in a patient with antithrombin Cambridge II. Sensitivity of the APC resistance test in the absence of factor V-deficient plasma was shown to be improved through normalization of results, and errors in the genetic diagnosis of factor V Leiden and the P20210A prothrombin gene mutation are described. Errors in the diagnosis of thrombophilic defects can therefore be identified through participation in EQA programs, and following dissemination of information, improvements in diagnosis can be demonstrated.
KEYWORDS
Quality assurance testing - antithrombin - protein C - protein S - activated protein C resistance - factor V Leiden - prothrombin gene mutation
REFERENCES
1 Faioni E M, Mannucci P M. Diagnostic testing for familial thrombophilia. In: Rowan RM, van Assendelft OW, Preston FE Advanced Laboratory Methods in Haematology London; Arnold 2002
2
Egeberg O.
On the natural blood coagulation system. Investigations of inhibitor factors based on antithrombin deficient blood.
Thromb Diath Haemorrh.
1965;
14
473-489
3
Haemostasis and Thrombosis Task Force, British Committee for Standards in Haematology. Investigation and management of heritable thrombophilia.
Br J Haematol.
2001;
114
512-528
4
Tripodi A, Mannucci P M.
Laboratory investigation of thrombophilia.
Clin Chem.
2001;
47
1597-1606
5 Torrano-Masetti L, Rizzatti E G, Oliveira L CO, Inácio R A, Santos M A, Franco R F. Psychologic impact of thrombophilia screening in asymptomatic relatives of carriers of prothrombotic mutations. J Thromb Haemost 2003 1(suppl 1): (abst OC322)
6
Greaves M, Cohen H, Machin S J, Mackie I.
Guidelines on the investigation and management of the antiphospholipid syndrome.
Br J Haematol.
2000;
109
704-715
7
Kitchen S, Walker I D, Woods TA L, Preston F E. on behalf of the Steering Committee of the UK NEQAS in Blood Coagulation .
Thromboplastin related differences in the determination of International Normalised Ratio: A cause for concern?.
Thromb Haemost.
1994;
72
426-429
8
Jennings I, Kitchen S, Cooper P, Makris M, Preston F E.
Sensitivity of functional protein S assays to protein S deficiency: a comparative study of three commercial kits.
J Thromb Haemost.
2003;
1
1112-1114
9
Preston F E, Kitchen S, Jennings I, Woods T A.
A UK National External Quality Assessment scheme (UK NEQAS) for molecular genetic testing for the diagnosis of familial thrombophilia.
Thromb Haemost.
1999;
82
1556-1557
10
Cunningham M T, Praestgaard J, Styer P E et al..
A method for proficiency testing of small peer groups in the College of American Pathologists Coagulation Surveys.
Arch Pathol Lab Med.
1999;
123
199-205
11
Meijer P, Kluft C, Haverkate F, De Maat M P.
The long-term within- and between-laboratory variability for assay of antithrombin, and proteins C and S: results derived from the external quality assessment program for thrombophilia screening of the ECAT Foundation.
J Thromb Haemost.
2003;
1
748-753
12
Faioni E M, Franchi F, Asti D, Sacchi E, Bernardi F, Mannucci P M.
Resistance to activated protein C in nine thrombophilic families: interference in a protein S functional assay.
Thromb Haemost.
1993;
70
1067-1071
13
Cooper P C, Hampton K K, Makris M, Abuzenadah A, Paul B, Preston F E.
Further evidence that activated protein C resistance can be misdiagnosed as inherited functional protein S deficiency.
Br J Haematol.
1994;
88
201-203
14
Ireland H, Bayston T, Thompson E et al..
Apparent heterozygous type II protein C deficiency caused by the factor V 506 Arg to Gln mutation.
Thromb Haemost.
1995;
73
731-732
15
Simioni P, de Ronde H, Prandoni P, Saladini M, Bertina R M, Girolami A.
Ischemic stroke in young patients with activated protein C resistance: a report of three cases belonging to three different kindreds.
Stroke.
1995;
26
885-890
16
Jennings I, Kitchen S, Cooper P C, Rimmer J E, Woods T A, Preston F E.
Further evidence that activated protein C resistance affects protein C coagulant activity assays.
Thromb Haemost.
2000;
83
171-172
17
De Stefano V, Finazzi G, Mannucci P M.
Inherited thrombophilia: pathogenesis, clinical syndromes and management.
Blood.
1996;
87
3531-3544
18
Lane D A, Mannucci P M, Bauer K A et al..
Inherited thrombophilia, Part 1.
Thromb Haemost.
1996;
76
651-662
19 Faioni E M. Protein S activity. In: Jespersen J, Bertina RM, Haverkate F Laboratory Techniques in Thrombosis: A Manual Amsterdam; Kluwer Academic 1999
20
Demers C, Henderson P, Blajchman M A et al..
An antithrombin III assay based on factor Xa inhibition provides a more reliable test to identify congenital antithrombin III deficiency than an assay based on thrombin inhibition.
Thromb Haemost.
1993;
69
231-235
21
De Visser M C, Rosendaal F R, Bertina R M.
A reduced sensitivity for activated protein C in the absence of factor V Leiden increases the risk of venous thrombosis.
Blood.
1999;
93
1271-1276
22
De Ronde H, Bertina M.
Laboratory diagnosis of APC resistance: a critical evaluation of the test and development of diagnostic criteria.
Thromb Haemost.
1994;
72
880-886
23
Tripodi A, Chantarangkul V, Negri B, Mannucci P M.
Standardisation of the APC resistance test. Effects of normalisation of results by means of pooled normal plasma.
Thromb Haemost.
1998;
79
564-566
24
Jennings I, Kitchen S, Woods T A, Preston F E.
Normalization does not improve between-laboratory agreement but may improve specificity of some assays for activated protein C resistance.
Blood Coagul Fibrinolysis.
1999;
10
451-453
25
Brandt G, Gruppo R, Glueck C J et al..
Sensitivity, specificity and predictive value of modified assays for activated protein C resistance in children.
Thromb Haemost.
1998;
79
567-570
26
Lutz C T, Foster P A, Noll W W et al..
Multicenter evaluation of PCR methods for the detection of factor V Leiden (R506Q) genotypes.
Clin Chem.
1998;
44
1356-1358
27
Tripodi A, Peyvandi F, Chantarangkul V, Menegatti M, Mannucci P M.
Relatively poor performance of clinical laboratories for DNA analyses in the detection of two thrombophilic mutations-a cause for concern.
Thromb Haemost.
2002;
88
690-691
28
Jennings I, Kitchen S, Woods T AL, Preston F E, Greaves M.
Clinically important inaccuracies in testing for the lupus anticoagulant: an analysis of results from three surveys of the UK NEQAS for Blood Coagulation.
Thromb Haemost.
1997;
77
934-937
29
Jennings I, Greaves M, Mackie I J, Kitchen S, Woods T A, Preston F E.
UK National External Quality Assessment Scheme for Blood Coagulation. Lupus anticoagulant testing: improvements in performance in a UK NEQAS proficiency testing exercise after dissemination of national guidelines on laboratory methods.
Br J Haematol.
2002;
119
364-369
30
Jennings I, Kitchen S, Smith J, Woods T A, Preston F E.
Between-centre agreement in homocysteine assays: experience from the UK NEQAS proficiency testing scheme.
Thromb Haemost.
2002;
87
921-922
Ian JenningsPh.D.
UK NEQAS for Blood Coagulation, Rutledge Mews, 3 Southbourne Road
Sheffield S10 2QN, United Kingdom
Email: ian@coageqa.org.uk