The First World War (also known as World War I or the Great War) was a global war,
beginning on 28 July 1914, until 11 November 1918. This large conflict involved countries
that organized themselves in two opposing lines: the Allies or Triple Entente (including
the United Kingdom, France and Russia), versus the Central Powers or Triple Alliance
(Germany and Austria-Hungary). Although Italy was a member of the Triple Alliance,
these alliances reorganized and expanded as more nations entered the war: Italy, Japan
and the United States joined the Allies, while the Ottoman Empire and Bulgaria joined
the Central Powers.
The trigger for the war was the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria,
but other political questions related to the foreign imperialist policies of the great
powers of Europe were also at stake. In this Great War, which was one of the largest
in history, more than 70 million servicemen, including 60 million from Europe, were
mobilized. With technological advancement and increased lethality of weapons, more
than nine million soldiers were killed on battlefields.
Following an initial period of mobile warfare, trench warfare became the dominant
setting for the WWI battles at the Western front. The armies protected themselves
in extensive lines of earth that were dug by the soldiers ([Figure 1]). This was the most lethal phase of the Great War. Many soldiers fell victim to
shell explosions, machine gun fire, and toxic gas. Hygiene was precarious, trenches
were infested with parasites and vermin, and soldiers were constantly exposed to infectious
diseases.
Figure 1 German battery of chlorine gas cylinders being prepared for an attack, awaiting the
right weather conditions to prevent blowback; similar to the arrangement at Hill 60
in May 1915, open domain.
Soon after the beginning of the war, soldiers on both sides started to present in
large numbers with neurological symptoms, such as dizziness, tremor, tinnitus, amnesia,
weakness and headache. Despite the symptoms, many cases presented no evidence of physical
injury. Many physicians concluded that the intensity of the bombings, the constant
sight of dead comrades, and the uncertainty of coming out alive, must have contributed
to the reactions of these soldiers[1],[2]. This condition was known as “shell shock”, or “war neurosis”, which shares features
with (but is not the same) as present-day post-traumatic stress disorder[3]. In his seminal article on shell shock in the Lancet, published in 1915, Myers described
three soldiers who had suffered vision loss, hearing and smell changes, and memory
loss without obvious physical injuries ([Figure 2])[4]. It became increasingly clear to physicians in Britain, Germany and other countries
that these syndromes bore similarity with the hysterical presentations discussed by
Charcot and his colleagues in nineteenth century Paris[3].
Figure 2 First article published related to the Shell Shock in the First World War, in 1915,
by Dr. Charles Myers, captain – Royal Army Medical Corps, in The Lancet. In this paper,
Myers described neurological symptoms characterized by vision loss, hearing and smell
changes, and memory loss related to the Shell Shock.
However, not everyone conceptualized shell shock in this functional or psychological
way. Several doctors believed in hidden brain injuries and others suspected carbon
monoxide poisoning. Some doctors even accused shell shocked soldiers of malingering
and actively trying to avoid their military duty, although actual punishment under
military law was rare[3].
Major Arthur Hurst, a physician with a strong interest in Neurology and good contacts
with leading French neurologists, made a major contribution to the understanding and
treatment of shell shocked soldiers, Hurst’s description of the clinical phenotype
of shell shock was striking[5],[6]. Many soldiers had paraplegia, ataxia, tremor, and mutism of psychosomatic origin
and others psychogenic movement disorders ([Figure 3]). Numerous films were produced at the time, one of them by Arthur Hurst himself,
in order to demonstrate the successful treatment through hypnotic suggestion and other
techniques[7].
Figure 3 Images of “shell shock”, with different neurological manifestation, scanned from
Arthur Hurst’s book: Arthur Hurst, Medical Diseases of the War (London: Edward Arnold, 1918).
It is very interesting to compare shell shock and other “war syndromes”. In the Persian
Gulf War (1990-1991), 25% to 30% of veterans developed a complex syndrome that included
chronic fatigue, pain, cognitive and affective dysfunction and other “functional”
interoceptive and nociceptive complaints. This syndrome was termed Gulf War Illness
(GWI)[8]. There is an ongoing debate on the relative contribution of organic (particularly
toxic) and psychological (combat stress) factors, which is often politically charged,
and very similar to the debates around shell shock a century ago.
In France, the most dramatic representation of shell shock was “camptocormie”[9]. The neurologists Achille Alexandre Souques and Inna Rosanoff-Saloff proposed this
term characterized by an abnormal position of the trunk with marked flexion of the
thoraco-lumbar spine, which increases during walking and abates in the recumbent position.
The abnormal posture was assumed to be a psychogenic disorder described as a conversion
reaction during the First World War in male military recruits and soldiers who were
unable to cope with the stress of combat and unpleasant military life, perhaps triggered
by stooped posture when walking in the trenches.
Considering therapeutic options, in 1916, Clovis Vincent, pioneer of neurosurgery
in France, developed a method called torpillage (a term created by the soldiers themselves with the meaning of torpedoing), a “persuasive”
form of psychotherapy using faradic and galvanic electric currents, to treat soldiers
with camptocormia and “intractable” neuroses[10]. Electrotherapy was popular for some time during the war in other countries as well,
although some forms were banned by the authorities.
A century ago, there was an “epidemic” of neurological conversion symptoms, the condition
called shell shock. It is still fascinating for today’s neurologists and psychiatrists
to watch the film documentaries and read the detailed case reports, such as those
preserved in the archives of the National Hospital at Queen Square in London ([Figure 4]). Because medically-unexplained symptoms remain a major challenge and, considering
the close relationship of symptoms described in shell shock with clinical neurology,
we should study their history in order to improve future care.
Figure 4 National Hospital for the Paralysed and Epileptic, around 1914, Queen Square Archives,
QSA/15445.
Acknowledgements: The authors thank Professor Andrew J. Lees (UCL, Institute of Neurology,
National Hospital for Neurology and Neurosurgery, Queen Square, London, UK) and Dr.
Stefanie C. Linden (Division of Psychological Medicine and Clinical Neurosciences,
School of Medicine, Cardiff University, Cardiff CF24 4HQ, UK) who provided the images,
performed a critical review and participated as co-authors of this manuscript.
