Supporting Creativity and Appreciation of Uncertainty in Exploring Geo-coded Public Health Data

Summary

Background and Objectives: We present a prototype visualisation tool, ADVISES (Adaptive Visualization for e-Science), designed to support epidemiologists and public health practitioners in exploring geo-coded datasets and generating spatial epidemiological hypotheses. The tool is designed to support creative thinking while providing the means for the user to evaluate the validity of the visualization in terms of statistical uncertainty. We present an overview of the application and the results of an evaluation exploring public health researchers’ responses to maps as a new way of viewing familiar data, in particular the use of thematic maps with adjoining descriptive statistics and forest plots to support the generation and evaluation of new hypotheses.

Methods: A series of qualitative evaluations involved one experienced researcher asking 21 volunteers to interact with the system to perform a series of relatively complex, realistic map-building and exploration tasks, using a ‘think aloud’ protocol, followed by a semi-structured interview The volunteers were academic epidemiologists and UK National Health Service analysts.

Results: All users quickly and confidently created maps, and went on to spend substantial amounts of time exploring and interacting with system, generating hypotheses about their maps.

Conclusions: Our findings suggest that the tool is able to support creativity and statistical appreciation among public health professionals and epidemiologists building thematic maps. Software such as this, introduced appropriately, could increase the capability of existing personnel for generating public health intelligence.

Keywords

Epidemiology - creativity - geographic information systems - visualization - public health

• References

• 1 Shneiderman B. Leonardo’s Laptop. 1st ed. MIT Press; 2003
• 2 Health Survey For England. 1991-2007.. Distributed by the Economic and Social Data Service. Available from: http://www.esds.ac.uk/government/hse/
• 3 Hey T, Trefethen A. The Data Deluge: An e-Science Perspective. In: Berman F, Fox G, Hey A. (eds). Grid Computing – Making the Global Infrastructure a Reality. Wiley: 2003
• 4 Kell D, Oliver S. Here is the evidence, now what is the hypothesis?. BioEssays 2004; 26 (01) 99-105.
• 5 Saxon G. Enhancing Creativity in Epidemiology. American Journal of Epidemiology 1988; 158 (02) 249-253.
• 6 Clarke K, McLafferty S, Tempalski B. On epidemiology and geographic information systems: a review and discussion of future directions. Emerg Infect Dis 1996; 2 (02) 85-92.
• 7 Driedger SM, Kothari A, Morrison J, Sawada M, Crighton E, Graham I. Correction: Using participa-tory design to develop (public) health decision support systems through GIS. 2007: 53.
• 8 Gao S, Mioc D, Anton F, Yi X, Coleman D. Online GIS services for mapping and sharing disease information. 2008: 8.
• 9 Jacquez GM. Spatial analysis in epidemiology: Nascent science or a failure of GIS?. Journal of Geographical Systems 2000; 2 (01) 91-97.
• 10 Instant Atlas, http://www.instantatlas.com , 10th November 09
• 11 Epi Info, http://www.cdc.gov/epiinfo , 10th November 09
• 12 Thew S, Sutcliffe A, Procter R, Bruijn Od, McNaught J, Venters CC. et al. Requirements Engineering for E-science: Experiences in Epidemiology. IEEE Software 2009; 26 (01) 80-87.
• 13 Amar R, Stasko J. A knowledge task-based framework for design and evaluation of information visualisations. Infovis’04. Austin, Texas, USA 2004
• 14 Krieger N. Place, Space and Health: GIS and Epidemiology. Epidemiology 2003; 14 (04) 384-385.
• 15 Richards T, Croner C, Rushton G, Brown C, Fowler L. Geographic Information Systems and Public Health: Mapping the Future. Public Health Reports 1999; 114: 359-373.
• 16 Lewis S, Clarke M. Forest plots: trying to see the wood for the trees. British Medical Journal 2001; 322 7300 1479-1480.
• 17 Sutcliffe A. User-Centred Requirements Engineering – Theory and Practice. 1st ed. Springer; 2002
• 18 Ericsson K, Simon H. Protocol Analysis: Verbal Reports as Data. 2nd ed. Boston: MIT Press; 1993
• 19 Isen AM, Daubman KA, Nowicki GP. Positive affect facilitates creative problem solving. Journal of personality and social psychology. 1987 ; 52 (6)
• 20 Buchan I, Winn J, Bishop C. A unified modelling approach to data intensive healthcare. In the fourth paradigm. Data-intensive scientific discovery. In: Hey T, Tansley S, Tolle K. (eds). The fourth paradigm Data-intensive scientific discovery: Microsoft Research; 2009