Reporting Practices on Immunosuppression and Rejection Management in Face Transplantation: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Background Face transplantation is a demanding operation requiring complex planning and expert technical performance. While the documentation of successes of the first transplants is impressive, there are lacunae in reporting of institutional protocols for other critical operation components, namely, immunosuppression, graft surveillance, and management of rejection and graft failure. The purpose of this review is to assess protocol reporting by face transplant teams to determine where we, as a plastic surgery community, can improve.

Methods A systematic review of PubMed was conducted to identify literature on face transplants published from November, 2005, starting with the first successful transplant to December, 2018. English-language articles were reviewed for reporting of protocols on antimicrobial prophylaxis, immunosuppression, graft surveillance, and management of rejection and graft failure.

Results A total of 44 face transplantation patients were identified. Protocols for antimicrobial prophylaxis, immunosuppressive induction, and maintenance immunosuppression were reported for 61%, 75%, and 73% of patients, respectively. Protocols for graft surveillance and medical management of rejection were reported for 70% of patients in both cases. Surgical salvage strategies to manage graft failure were documented for 43% of patients.

Conclusion The current literature on face transplantation does not include consistent reporting on critical aspects of patient care. Medical protocols outlining guidelines for immunosuppression, graft surveillance, and management of rejection and graft failure are the most critical factors determining overall transplant success. However, they are underreported in the literature. Development and communication of standardized protocols is essential to improve patient outcomes and maximize the results of this procedure.

Keywords

face transplantation - rejection management - protocol reporting

• References

• 1 Gottlieb LJ, Krieger LM. From the reconstructive ladder to the reconstructive elevator. Plast Reconstr Surg 1994; 93 (07) 1503-1504
• 2 Pennell CP, Hirst AD, Campbell WB. , et al. Practical guide to the Idea, development and exploration stages of the IDEAL framework and recommendations. Br J Surg 2016; 103 (05) 607-615
• 3 McCulloch P, Cook JA, Altman DG, Heneghan C, Diener MK. ; IDEAL Group. IDEAL framework for surgical innovation 1: the idea and development stages. BMJ 2013; 346: f3012
• 4 Carty MJ, Hivelin M, Dumontier C. , et al. Lessons learned from simultaneous face and bilateral hand allotransplantation. Plast Reconstr Surg 2013; 132 (02) 423-432
• 5 Kanitakis J, Petruzzo P, Gazarian A. , et al. Premalignant and malignant skin lesions in two recipients of vascularized composite tissue allografts (face, hands). Case Rep Transplant 2015; 2015: 356459
• 6 Morelon E, Petruzzo P, Kanitakis J, Dakpe S, Thaunat O, Dubois V. , et al. Face transplantation: partial graft loss of the first case 10 years later. Am J Transplant 2017; 17 (07) 1935-1940
• 7 Petruzzo P, Kanitakis J, Testelin S, Pialat JB, Buron F, Badet L. , et al. Clinicopathological findings of chronic rejection in a face grafted patient. Transplantation 2015; 99 (12) 2644-2650
• 8 Krezdorn N, Lian CG, Wells M, Wo L, Tasigiorgos S, Xu S. , et al. Chronic rejection of human face allografts. Am J Transplant 2019; 19 (04) 1168-1177
• 9 Ozkan O, Ozkan O, Dogan U, Yilmaz VT, Uysal H, Undar L. , et al. Consideration of difficulties and exit strategies in a case of face allotransplantation resulting in failure. Microsurgery 2017; 37 (06) 661-668
• 10 Man's second face transplant is a world first [Internet]. CNN; 2018 . Availabel at: https://www.cnn.com/2018/04/17/health/second-face-transplant-bn/index.html . Accessed April 17, 2018
• 11 Transplanted face rejected: “Now we need a new donor” [Internet]. Corriere Della Sera; 2018 . Available at: https://www.corriere.it/english/18_settembre_25/transplanted-face-rejected-now-we-need-new-donor-0916a0ea-c0d2-11e8-8c2f-234b69fe8a3d.shtml?refresh_ce-cp . Accessed September 25, 2018
• 12 Sosin M, Rodriguez ED. The Face Transplantation Update: 2016. Plast Reconstr Surg 2016; 137 (06) 1841-1850
• 13 First face transplant patient Isabelle Dinoire dies in France [Internet]. BBC News; 2016 . Available at: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-37290986 . Accessed September 6, 2016
• 14 Hatice Nergis dies the first woman who had a face transplant in Turkey [Internet]. Hurriyet; 2016 . Available at: http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/turkiyenin-yuz-nakli-yapilan-ilk-kadini-hatice-nergis-oldu-40278523 . Accessed November 15, 2017
• 15 Pomahac B, Pribaz J, Eriksson E, Annino D, Caterson S, Sampson C. , et al. Restoration of facial form and function after severe disfigurement from burn injury by a composite facial allograft. Am J Transplant 2011; 11 (02) 386-393
• 16 Chang J, Davis CL, Mathes DW. The impact of current immunosuppression strategies in renal transplantation on the field of reconstructive transplantation. J Reconstr Microsurg 2012; 28: 7-19
• 17 Westvik TS, Dermietzel A, Pomahac B. Facial restoration by transplantation: the Brigham and Women's face transplant experience. Ann Plast Surg 2015; 74 (Suppl. 01) S2-S8
• 18 Kueckelhaus M, Fischer S, Seyda M, Bueno EM, Aycart MA. , et al. Vascularized composite allotransplantation: current standards and novel approaches to prevent acute rejection and chronic allograft deterioration. Transpl Int 2016; 29: 655-662
• 19 Enderby C, Keller CA. An overview of immunosuppression in solid organ transplantation. Am J Manag Care 2015; 21 (1 Suppl): s12-23
• 20 Cimino FM, Snyder KA. Primary Care of the Solid Organ Transplant Recipient. Am Fam Physician 2016; 93 (03) 203-210
• 21 Kaminska-Winciorek G, Giebel S, Lange D, Maciejewski A. Dermoscopy in near-full facial transplantation. J Am Acad Dermatol 2015; 72 (1 Suppl): S19-S21
• 22 Roche NA, Vermeersch HF, Stillaert FB, Peters KT, De Cubber J, Van Lierde K. , et al. Complex facial reconstruction by vascularized composite allotransplantation: the first Belgian case. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg 2015; 68 (03) 362-371
• 23 Diaz-Siso JR, Fischer S, Sisk GC, Bueno E, Kueckelhaus M, Talbot S. , et al. Initial experience of dual maintenance immunosuppression with steroid withdrawal in vascular composite tissue allotransplantation. Am J Transplant 2015; 15 (05) 1421-1431
• 24 Bergfeld W, Klimczak A, Stratton JS, Siemionow MZ. A four-year pathology review of the near total face transplant. Am J Transplant 2013; 13 (10) 2750-2764
• 25 Khalifian S, Brazio PS, Mohan R, Shaffer C, Brandacher G, Barth RN. , et al. Facial transplantation: the first 9 years. Lancet 2014; 384 (9960): 2153-2163
• 26 Iyer S. Vascularised composite allotransplants: Transplant of upper extremities and face. Indian J Plast Surg 2015; 48 (02) 111-118
• 27 Lin S. Immunosuppressive strategies in solid organ transplantation. N Engl J Med 2004; 351: 2715-2729 In: Pharmacotherapy Self-Assessment Program. 5th ed.
• 28 Wo L, Bueno E, Pomahac B. Facial transplantation: worth the risks? A look at evolution of indications over the last decade. Curr Opin Organ Transplant 2015; 20 (06) 615-620
• 29 Guo S, Han Y, Zhang X, Lu B, Yi C, Zhang H. , et al. Human facial allotransplantation: a 2-year follow-up study. Lancet 2008; 372 (9639): 631-638
• 30 Roche NA, Blondeel PN, Van Lierde KM, Vermeersch HF. Facial transplantation: history and update. Acta Chir Belg 2015; 115 (02) 99-103
• 31 Nacif LS, Pinheiro RS, Pecora RA, Ducatti L, Rocha-Santos V, Andraus W. , et al. Late acute rejection in liver transplant: a systematic review. Arq Bras Cir Dig 2015; 28 (03) 212-215
• 32 Lantieri L, Hivelin M, Audard V, Benjoar MD, Meningaud JP, Bellivier F. , et al. Feasibility, reproducibility, risks and benefits of face transplantation: a prospective study of outcomes. Am J Transplant 2011; 11 (02) 367-378
• 33 Rana A, Gruessner A, Agopian VG, Khalpey Z, Riaz IB, Kaplan B. , et al. Survival benefit of solid-organ transplant in the United States. JAMA Surg 2015; 150 (03) 252-259
• 34 Keller CA. Solid organ transplantation overview and delection criteria. Am J Manag Care 2015; 21 (1 Suppl): S4-S11
• 35 Diaz-Siso JR, Borab ZM, Plana NM, Parent B, Stranix JT. , et al. Vascularized Composite Allotransplantation: Alternatives and Catch-22s. Plast Reconstr Surg 2018; 142: 1320-1326
• 36 Massie AB, Kucirka LM, Segev DL. Big data in organ transplantation: registries and administrative claims. Am J Transplant 2014; 14 (08) 1723-1730
• 37 Data Collection and Submission Requirements for Vascularized Composite Allografts (VCAs). In: Network OPaT, ed. OPTN Policies 181 and 182. Health Resources & Services Administration: U.S. Department of Health & Human Services; 2014
• 38 Devauchelle B, Badet L, Lengele B, Morelon E, Testelin S, Michallet M. , et al. First human face allograft: early report. Lancet 2006; 368 (9531): 203-209
• 39 Dubernard JM, Lengele B, Morelon E, Testelin S, Badet L, Moure C. , et al. Outcomes 18 months after the first human partial face transplantation. N Engl J Med 2007; 357 (24) 2451-2460
• 40 Petruzzo P, Testelin S, Kanitakis J, Badet L, Lengele B, Girbon JP. , et al. First human face transplantation: 5 years outcomes. Transplantation 2012; 93 (02) 236-240
• 41 Kanitakis J, Badet L, Petruzzo P, Beziat JL, Morelon E, Lefrancois N. , et al. Clinicopathologic monitoring of the skin and oral mucosa of the first human face allograft: Report on the first eight months. Transplantation 2006; 82 (12) 1610-1615
• 42 Petruzzo P, Kanitakis J, Badet L, Pialat JB, Boutroy S, Charpulat R. , et al. Long-term follow-up in composite tissue allotransplantation: in-depth study of five (hand and face) recipients. Am J Transplant 2011; 11 (04) 808-816
• 43 Lantieri L, Meningaud JP, Grimbert P, Bellivier F, Lefaucheur JP, Ortonne N. , et al. Repair of the lower and middle parts of the face by composite tissue allotransplantation in a patient with massive plexiform neurofibroma: a 1-year follow-up study. Lancet 2008; 372 (9639): 639-645
• 44 Lantieri L, Grimbert P, Ortonne N, Suberbielle C, Bories D, Gil-Vernet S. , et al. Face transplant: long-term follow-up and results of a prospective open study. Lancet 2016; 388 (10052): 1398-1407
• 45 Siemionow M, Papay F, Alam D, Bernard S, Djohan R, Gordon C. , et al. Near-total human face transplantation for a severely disfigured patient in the USA. Lancet 2009; 374 (9685): 203-209
• 46 Siemionow MZ, Papay F, Djohan R, Bernard S, Gordon CR, Alam D. , et al. First U.S. near-total human face transplantation: a paradigm shift for massive complex injuries. Plast Reconstr Surg 2010; 125 (01) 111-122
• 47 Diaz-Siso JR, Parker M, Bueno EM, Sisk GC, Pribaz JJ, Eriksson E. , et al. Facial allotransplantation: a 3-year follow-up report. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg 2013; 66 (11) 1458-1463
• 48 Westvik TS, Dermietzel A, Pomahac B. Facial restoration by transplantation: the Brigham and Women's face transplant experience. Ann Plast Surg 2015; 74 (Suppl. 01) S2-S8
• 49 Borges TJ, O'Malley JT, Wo L, Murakami N, Smith B, Azzi J. , et al. Codominant Role of Interferon-gamma- and Interleukin-17-Producing T Cells During Rejection in Full Facial Transplant Recipients. Am J Transplant 2016; 16 (07) 2158-2171
• 50 Kollar B, Pomahac B. Facial restoration by transplantation. Surgeon 2018; 16 (04) 245-249
• 51 Pomahac B, Bueno EM, Sisk GC, Pribaz JJ. Current principles of facial allotransplantation: the Brigham and Women's Hospital Experience. Plast Reconstr Surg 2013; 131 (05) 1069-1076
• 52 Cavadas PC, Ibanez J, Thione A. Surgical aspects of a lower face, mandible, and tongue allotransplantation. J Reconstr Microsurg 2012; 28 (01) 43-47
• 53 Sicilia-Castro D, Gomez-Cia T, Infante-Cossio P, Gacto-Sanchez P, Barrera-Pulido F, Lagares-Borrego A. , et al. Reconstruction of a severe facial defect by allotransplantation in neurofibromatosis type 1: a case report. Transplant Proc 2011; 43 (07) 2831-2837
• 54 Barret JP, Gavalda J, Bueno J, Nuvials X, Pont T, Masnou N. , et al. Full face transplant: the first case report. Ann Surg 2011; 254 (02) 252-256
• 55 Janis JE, MacKenzie KD, Wright SE, Pomahac B, Lu C, Susa J. , et al. Management of steroid-resistant late acute cellular rejection following face transplantation: a case report. Transplant Proc 2015; 47 (01) 223-225
• 56 Pomahac B, Pribaz J, Eriksson E, Bueno EM, Diaz-Siso JR, Rybicki FJ. , et al. Three patients with full facial transplantation. N Engl J Med 2012; 366 (08) 715-722
• 57 Özkan Ö, Özkan Ö, Ubur M, Hadimioğlu N, Cengiz M, Afşar İ. Face allotransplantation for various types of facial disfigurements: a series of five cases. Microsurgery 2018; 38 (08) 834-843
• 58 Operations successful and transplant patients stable: doctors [Internet]. Hurriyet Daily News; 2012 ; February 26 [cited 7/26/2016]. Available at: http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/operations-successful-and-transplant-patients-stable-doctors.aspx?pageID=238&nID=14651&NewsCatID=341
• 59 Dorafshar AH, Bojovic B, Christy MR, Borsuk DE, Iliff NT, Brown EN. , et al. Total face, double jaw, and tongue transplantation: an evolutionary concept. Plast Reconstr Surg 2013; 131 (02) 241-251
• 60 Chaudhry A, Sosin M, Bojovic B, Christy MR, Drachenberg CB, Rodriguez ED. Defining the Role of Skin and Mucosal Biopsy in Facial Allotransplantation: A 2-Year Review and Analysis of Histology. Plast Reconstr Surg 2015; 136 (03) 559-567
• 61 Diaz-Siso JR, Sosin M, Plana NM, Rodriguez ED. Face transplantation: Complications, implications, and an update for the oncologic surgeon. J Surg Oncol 2016; 113 (08) 971-975
• 62 Chandraker A, Arscott R, Murphy GF, Lian CG, Bueno EM, Marty FM. , et al. The management of antibody-mediated rejection in the first presensitized recipient of a full-face allotransplant. Am J Transplant 2014; 14 (06) 1446-1452
• 63 Maciejewski A, Krakowczyk L, Szymczyk C, Wierzgon J, Grajek M, Dobrut M. , et al. The First Immediate Face Transplant in the World. Ann Surg 2016; 263 (03) e36-e39
• 64 Polish woman undergoes full face transplant [Internet]. NY Daily News; 2013 . Available at: http://www.nydailynews.com/life-style/health/graphic-pics-polish-woman-full-face-transplant-article-1.1547027 . Accessed December 13, 2016
• 65 Man gets near-total face transplant [Internet]. CBS News; 2014 . Available at: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/man-gets-near-total-face-transplant/ . Accessed November 18, 2014
• 66 Hashem AM, Hoffman GS, Gastman B, Bernard S, Djohan R, Hendrickson M. , et al. Establishing the Feasibility of Face Transplantation in Granulomatosis With Polyangiitis. Am J Transplant 2016; 16 (07) 2213-2223
• 67 Fischer S, Lee TC, Krezdorn N, Alhefzi M, Kueckelhaus M, Bueno EM. , et al. First Lower Two-Thirds Osteomyocutaneous Facial Allograft Perfused by a Unilateral Facial Artery: Outcomes and Vascularization at 1 Year after Transplantation. Plast Reconstr Surg 2017; 139 (05) 1175e-1183e
• 68 Spain's pioneering Vall D'Hebron Hospital rebuilds man's face and neck during complex 27 hour operation [Internet]. The Independent; 2015 . Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/spains-pioneering-vall-dhebron-hospital-rebuilds-mans-face-and-neck-during-complex-27-hour-operation-10147420.html . Accessed March 31, 2018
• 69 First Russian undergoes face transplant operation [Internet]. Tass Russian News Agency; 2015 . Available at: http://tass.ru/en/science/839891 . Accessed November 27, 2016
• 70 Sosin M, Ceradini DJ, Levine JP, Hazen A, Staffenberg DA, Saadeh PB. , et al. Total Face, Eyelids, Ears, Scalp, and Skeletal Subunit Transplant: A Reconstructive Solution for the Full Face and Total Scalp Burn. Plast Reconstr Surg 2016; 138 (01) 205-219
• 71 Gelb BE, Diaz-Siso JR, Plana NM, Jacoby A, Rifkin WJ, Khouri KS. , et al. Absence of rejection in a facial allograft recipient with a positive flow crossmatch 24 months after induction with rabbit anti-thymocyte globulin and Anti-CD20 monoclonal antibody. Case Rep Transplant 2018; 2018: 7691072
• 72 Makitie AA, Salmi M, Lindford A, Tuomi J, Lassus P. Three-dimensional printing for restoration of the donor face: A new digital technique tested and used in the first facial allotransplantation patient in Finland. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg 2016; 69 (12) 1648-1652
• 73 Lassus P, Lindford A, Vuola J, Back L, Suominen S, Mesimaki K. , et al. The Helsinki Face Transplantation: Surgical aspects and 1-year outcome. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg 2018; 71 (02) 132-139
• 74 AP Exclusive: Twin tragedies give survivor a new face [Internet]. AP News; 2017 . Available at: https://apnews.com/326b2b9322f64ad4827edc87a76dc321/twin-tragedies-give-survivor-new-face-and-new-life . Accessed February 17, 2017
• 75 Cleveland Clinic performs third face transplant [Internet]. Cleveland Clinic Newsroom; 2017 . Available at: https://newsroom.clevelandclinic.org/2017/07/18/cleveland-clinic-performs-third-face-transplant/ . Accessed July 18, 2018
• 76 A Face Transplant Gave This 26-Year-Old a ‘Second Chance at Life’ – And Points to a Promising Future for Patients [Internet]. Time Magazine; 2018 . Available at: http://time.com/5466810/cameron-underwood-face-transplant/ . Accessed November 29,2018
• 77 ‘Six months before he's smiling’: Canada performs its first face transplant [Internet]. CTV News; 2018 . Available at: https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/six-months-before-he-s-smiling-canada-performs-its-first-face-transplant-1.4096874 . Accessed September 17, 2018
• 78 Rome, the first face transplant in Italy: 49 year old received the face of a 21 year old [Internet]. Archy Worldys; 2018 . Available at: https://www.archyworldys.com/rome-the-first-face-transplant-in-italy-49-year-old-received-the-face-of-a-21-year-old/ . Accessed September 22, 2018
• 79 Hashem AM, Djohan R, Bernard S, Hendrickson M, Schwarz G. , et al. Face Transplantation for Granulomatosis With Polyangiitis (Wegener Granulomatosis): technical considerations, immunological aspects, and 3-year posttransplant outcome. Ann Plast Surg 2019; 82 (03) 320-329