Biosystematic Studies on the Family Tofieldiaceae I. Phylogeny and Circumscription of the Family Inferred from DNA Sequences of matK and rbcL

Abstract

In order to specify phylogenetic positions of the genera of Tofieldiaceae (Tofieldia, Triantha, Pleea, Harperocallis, Isidrogalvia), and to suggest reasonable circumscription of the family and genera of Tofieldiaceae, we determined DNA sequences of matK and rbcL for each genus of the family, and analyzed them phylogenetically with the 45 families and 113 genera of the monocots other than Tofieldiaceae, whose matK and rbcL sequences have already been reported. We found that Tofieldia, Triantha, Pleea, and Harperocallis form the same clade, which receives 100 % bootstrap support. This clade can be regarded as corresponding to Tofieldiaceae, and is embedded in the clade of Alismatales (98 %). On the other hand, Isidrogalvia is not included in this Tofieldiaceae clade, and positioned as sister to Narthecium (100 %), embedded in the clade of Nartheciaceae (Dioscoreales) (100 %). In the Tofieldiaceae, Pleea first diverges from the remaining three genera (100 %), and then, Harperocallis diverges from the Tofieldia-Triantha complex (100 %). In the Tofieldia-Triantha complex, five Tofieldia species form the same clade (100 %), and two Triantha species form another clade (100 %). Thus, Isidrogalvia should be transferred from Tofieldiaceae to Nartheciaceae. As Isidrogalvia, as well as the Nartheciaceae, have the carpels that are fully connate into a single style, Isidrogalvia fits the Nartheciaceae well with respect to carpel connation. After this transfer, the Tofieldiaceae correspond mainly to plants with almost free carpels and three styles. Pleea is better treated as an independent genus than included in Tofieldia. Triantha can be treated either as an independent genus or as congeneric with Tofieldia.

Key words

Harperocallis - Isidrogalvia - matK - Nartheciaceae - Pleea - rbcL - Tofieldiaceae.

References

• 1 Ambrose J. D.. A re-evaluation of the Melanthioideae (Liliaceae) using numerical analyses. Brickell, C. D., Cutler, D. F., and Gregory, M., eds. Petaloid Monocotyledons, Linnean Society Symposium Series no. 8. London; Academic Press (1980): 65-81
• 2 APG (The Angiosperm Phylogeny Group) II . An update of the Angiosperm Phylogeny Group classification for the orders and families of flowering plants.  Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society. (2003);  141 399-436
• 3 Baker J. G.. A synopsis of Colchicaceae and the aberrant tribes of Liliaceae.  Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society. (1879);  17 405-510
• 4 Bentham G., Hooker J. D.. Genera Plantarum, Vol. 3. London; Reeve (1883): 1258
• 5 Cronquist A.. The Evolution and Classification of Flowering Plants, 2nd ed. The New York Botanical Garden (1988): 555
• 6 Cruden R. W.. A revision of Isidrogalvia (Liliaceae): Recognition for Ruíz and Pavón's genus.  Systematic Botany. (1991);  16 270-282
• 7 Engler A.. Liliaceae. Engler, A. and Prantl, K., eds. Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien, Vol. 2 (5). Leipzig; Engelmann (1888): 10-91
• 8 Fuse S., Tamura M. N.. A phylogenetic analysis of the plastid matK gene with emphasis on Melanthiaceae sensu lato. .  Plant Biology. (2000);  2 415-427
• 9 Gates R.. A systematic study of the North American Melanthaceae from the genetic standpoint.  Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society. (1918);  44 131-172
• 10 Hutchinson J.. The Families of Flowering Plants, Vol. 2. London; MacMillan (1934): 243
• 11 Krause K.. Liliaceae. Engler, A. and Prantl, K., eds. Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien, ed. 2, Vol. 15 a. Leipzig; Engelmann (1930): 227-386
• 12 Melchior H.. Liliaceae. Melchior, H., ed. A Engler's Syllabus der Pflanzenfamilien, Vol. 2. Berlin; Gebrüder Borntraeger (1964): 514-524
• 13 Packer J. G.. Two new combinations in Triantha (Liliaceae).  Novon. (1993);  3 278-279
• 14 Packer J. G.. Triantha. . Flora of North America Editorial Committee, ed. Flora of North America, Vol. 26. New York; Oxford University Press (2002): 61-64
• 15 Remizova M., Sokoloff D.. Inflorescence and floral morphology in Tofieldia (Tofieldiaceae) compared with Araceae, Acoraceae and Alismatales s.str.  Botanische Jahrbücher für Systematik, Pflanzengeschichte und Pflanzengeographie. (2003);  124 255-271
• 16 Tamura M. N.. Nartheciaceae. Kubitzki, K., ed. The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants, Vol. 3. Berlin; Springer (1998): 381-392
• 17 Tamura M. N., Yamashita J., Fuse S., Haraguchi M.. Molecular phylogeny of monocotyledons inferred from combined analysis of plastid matK and rbcL gene sequences.  Journal of Plant Research. (2004);  117 109-120
• 18 Thorne R. F.. Classification and geography of the flowering plants.  Botanical Review. (1992);  58 225-348
• 19 Utech F. H.. Floral vascular anatomy of Pleea tenuifolia Michx. (Liliaceae-Tofieldieae) and its reassignment to Tofieldia. .  Annals of the Carnegie Museum. (1978);  47 423-454
• 20 Utech F. H.. Liliaceae. Flora of North America Editorial Committee, ed. Flora of North America, Vol. 26. New York; Oxford University Press (2002): 50-347
• 21 Walker J. W.. Classification and evolution of the monocotyledons.  American Journal of Botany. (1986);  73 746-(abstract)

1 Concerning stat. nov. of the Tofieldioideae as well as the Japonolirieae in [Tamura (1998)], these names were not validly published because their references were not enough to validate the stat. nov. Minoru N. Tamura republishes these names here, with names of the following references as the basionyms.

Section Editor: F. Salamini